wang422003
wang422003 t1_j2zan9x wrote
Reply to [D]There is still no discussion nor response under my ICLR submission after two months. What do you think I should do? by minogame
That’s way better than mine. I posted dozens of comments, asking for discussion, because obviously there is one reviewer has not spend more than 10 minutes on reading my submission. But he didn’t response. And the other reviewers just edited their review, instead of joining the discussion. Well.
wang422003 t1_j30vur6 wrote
Reply to comment by emad_eldeen in [D]There is still no discussion nor response under my ICLR submission after two months. What do you think I should do? by minogame
Yeah I also think the reviewers who edited their reviews read my response. Actually, one of them claimed that he/she is not in my research field, so I sincerely asked for a discussion in my response, so that I can acknowledge how to make my paper readable for those not in the same research field. (Since my research topic is quite unpopular, this is the case.) But I waited for months, and got nothing. I am not sure that is it really a good way to ignore my response/request about the discussion? The scores on my submission diverge quite a lot, but none of the reviewers ever joined the discussion.