snorkelingatheist
snorkelingatheist t1_jb3abw5 wrote
Reply to comment by marketrent in Sea creatures in Greek manuscript and Norse mythology may have been whales with mouths agape — Fish instinctively swim toward apparent shelter of creature’s mouth, a phenomenon depicted in ancient texts as early as 2,000 years ago by marketrent
I don't understand this sentence (nothing to do with whales, but confusing)
In the Naturalist – a 2,000-year-old text that “preserves zoological
information brought to Egypt from India and the Middle East by early
natural historians like Herodotus, Ctesias, Aristotle and Plutarch” –
the ancient Greeks referred to the creature as aspidochelone.
How & why would Herodotus, Aristotle &co be bringing information " to Egypt from India & the Middle East" ?? Are any of them thought to have visited India? &, if so, it seems to me they would have brought the info to Greece, not to Egypt. I don't remember the dates, but there couldn't have been much going on in Alexandria at that period, if Aristotle did visit the place.
snorkelingatheist t1_jcie1uy wrote
Reply to comment by snorkelingatheist in Sea creatures in Greek manuscript and Norse mythology may have been whales with mouths agape — Fish instinctively swim toward apparent shelter of creature’s mouth, a phenomenon depicted in ancient texts as early as 2,000 years ago by marketrent
I see I got some upvotes on this, but I was/am asking a question. The statements i'm querying seem to me hazy & inexact. Does anybody know the source of this "information?"