mediadavid

mediadavid t1_jcatmjp wrote

personally I find the movies to be good on their own merits but relatively weak adaptations of Tolkein's actual work. There's a lot of the story, the characters and the world that is either dropped, simplified or changed to streamline the movie plot or alternately to add pointless melodrama and inter-character conflict. Frankly I think the movies are more 'generic fantasy' than the books, which can still be kinda weird.

Of course you may well not like them at that's ok.

5