loganab13

loganab13 t1_j9s8jic wrote

Reply to comment by WittyWest in Tile installed on concrete by foxrue

Quarry tile comes in everything from a dull white to a deep red in sizes from 4x4 up to 12x12. It is used everywhere from commercial kitchens to K12 educational environments to commercial automotive shops. I have dealt with literal tons of quarry tile in schools and homes built in the 1950’s to the early 2000’s and can confidently tell you it isn’t limited to red 6x6 tiles.

Just because you sell tile and have attended a handful of TCNA courses doesn’t make your knowledge the end-all, be-all. We’ll agree to disagree on this one.

10

loganab13 t1_j9s7a6n wrote

Reply to comment by WittyWest in Tile installed on concrete by foxrue

What the hell are you talking about?

  1. tile is absolutely laid on thinset with a notched trowel. The qualifiers “with” or “on” make zero difference in OP’s situation

  2. I never once stated it was unacceptable to lay tile on a concrete substrate

  3. This is absolutely quarry tile. I have either personally installed or overseen the install of this exact quarry tile nearly a dozen times in my two decade’s long career in various residential and commercial construction settings

  4. I asked if OP had clearer photos to adequately address the situation. Where you’re coming up with these wild generalizations is beyond me

41

loganab13 t1_j9rund4 wrote

Cement board is more than sufficient. The other options are nice and a lot easier to work with, but are also a lot more expensive. I’ve been in some form of residential or commercial construction for nearly two decades and 95% of the tile jobs in bathrooms had cement board behind them. Make sure your tile guy tapes the seams with fiber mesh and floats the joints with thinset and you won’t have any issues.

1

loganab13 t1_j9rjnyp wrote

Tile isn’t laid on grout, it’s laid on thinset mortar. This is called quarry tile. Can you get better photos of the grout you’re dealing with?

22

loganab13 t1_j6gfc0l wrote

Knockdown hides less than perfect finishing & is extremely common in tract/spec homes. Your best options are either skim coating the entire ceiling, or laminating with 1/4” rock. I would choose option #2.

4

loganab13 t1_j63l9y7 wrote

The only truly correct way to repair would to be skim coated in its entirety. A good finisher can skim coat and finish sand both walls in half the time a DIYer could individually fill 1000+ holes and spot sand every one. Plus, the end result will look a thousand times better.

I’ve worked with a lot of finishers over my years in commercial construction and it truly is an art form.

3