lameheavy t1_iyw49t6 wrote on December 4, 2022 at 5:10 PM

Reply to [D] NeurIPS 2022 Outstanding Paper modified results significantly in the camera ready by Even_Stay3387

Good on the authors for admitting the error and correcting the results. I do wonder how many times this happens where authors don’t make a correction.

lameheavy t1_ixsyiic wrote on November 26, 2022 at 2:28 AM

Reply to comment by the_universe_is_vast in [D] AISTATS 2023 reviews are out by von_oldmann

You’re good. Address the comments on the 5 and it’s 100%…honestly even with out that you’re fine

lameheavy t1_ixirprt wrote on November 23, 2022 at 7:19 PM

Reply to comment by Lopsided-Giraffe-671 in [D] AISTATS 2023 reviews are out by von_oldmann

Please update when you do:)

lameheavy t1_ixaz4r9 wrote on November 22, 2022 at 2:13 AM

Reply to comment by Outside-Fun-4954 in [D] AISTATS 2023 reviews are out by von_oldmann

I'm in a very similar situation myself. I'm not very hopeful that I can change their mind with a rebuttal. Gonna try and hope the meta-reviewer realizes how much that reviewer missed the mark. I hope AISTATS is still small enough for that much attention to detail (I know it's not just let me cope).