Zeebuss
Zeebuss t1_j9ur66e wrote
Reply to Reality is an openness that we can never fully grasp. We need closures as a means of intervening in the world. | Post-postmodern philosopher and critic of realism Hilary Lawson explains closure theory. by IAI_Admin
Well be needing a different term than "Post-postmodern".
Zeebuss t1_j8sol7z wrote
Reply to comment by Masimat in /r/philosophy Open Discussion Thread | February 13, 2023 by BernardJOrtcutt
The continuity of brain and consciousness is not something I think we have a clear answer on. "Are you the same consciousness before and after a lobotomy" seems to be in the same class as "if you split the corpus collosum is it two consciousnesses now" and "Is Phineas Gage the same person before and after his accident?"
It will depend on whether you conceive of consciousness as arising from and dependant on its material substrate, or if you think consciousness is universal and that brains/minds are sort of like "antennas" that can pick up conscious signals, or any of many other theories of consciousness!
Zeebuss t1_j5ktlt5 wrote
Reply to comment by gwmccull in Do beavers get splinters in their mouths, and if they do, how do they deal with them? by OldManIrv
"Dad Beaver, why do we keep building these crappy dams that don't work?"
"It's tradition, son."
Zeebuss t1_j5ksdm1 wrote
Reply to comment by SethSky in Before the Holocene were all humans hunter gatherers? by Kquinn87
Is it possible to ever know for certain that there weren't agricultural societies with simple degradable tools and buildings prior to the Neolithic revolution?
Zeebuss t1_j5koxla wrote
Reply to comment by mxjuno in Do other animals have dangerous pregnancies just like humans? by Level_Shift_7516
For humans, midwifery is one the oldest and most ubiquitous professions in history, we've been intervening in birth for as long as know anything about.
Animal birth as well, animal husbandry is at least as old as agricultural, but domestication was already well underway among pre-agricultural nomadic societies.
Neither of these practices of artificial selection and assisted birth are "a few generations" old. They are ancient and absolutely have had enough generations for significant adaptation to occur. Also human artificial selection can happen much faster than that.
Zeebuss t1_j3wygf7 wrote
Reply to comment by JudoTrip in Philosophy has never been the detached pursuit of truth. It’s always been deeply invested in its own cultural perspective. by IAI_Admin
Normally I have to browse /r/occult for schizophrenia of this quality.
Zeebuss t1_j1rve8c wrote
Reply to comment by hecaton_atlas in /r/philosophy Open Discussion Thread | December 26, 2022 by BernardJOrtcutt
To me a philosophical statement is any one about how someone should live life. It could be a statement about lifestyles, morals, good vs evil, priorities, choices, etc.
It's a broad definition, but I take philosophy very broadly.
Zeebuss t1_ixsckrg wrote
Reply to comment by amann93 in Dissociative symptoms are common among individuals with depression, study finds by chrisdh79
That Isn't dissociation, it's a very normal part of how tedious repetitive actions get wiped from memory.
Zeebuss t1_j9uv1m9 wrote
Reply to Reality is an openness that we can never fully grasp. We need closures as a means of intervening in the world. | Post-postmodern philosopher and critic of realism Hilary Lawson explains closure theory. by IAI_Admin
Nice video, particularly enjoyed the random dude swimming in the river in the background lol.
He spoke well on the way we psychologically close off, or narrow our worldview, in order to make assessments and decisions. He did not articulate very well what full closedness would be like if it's possible, or what dangers that would pose.
His discussion of politics is also pretty conventional. "Be open to new ideas" is a pretty basic tenet of good faith debate, but individuals are still left to go out into the world and close it off in various ways to determine what's true, what a political response should look like, and what policies to pursue. If you care about consequences, maximal openness is not necessarily superior.
As for how to find that balance between closedness and openness He doesn't tell us much other than finding the balance is important, without any practical way of knowing when you're "open enough".