SkeeringReal
SkeeringReal t1_iyyntvj wrote
Reply to [D] Score 4.5 GNN paper from Muhan Zhang at Peking University was amazingly accepted by NeurIPS 2022 by Even_Stay3387
That is pretty crazy, but not unheard of I guess.
Indeed the reviews did reply mostly, so saying they're outdated makes little sense.
Does seem to be a bit fishy, but who knows I guess, if it's a bad paper who cares if it's. published or not, no one will read it regardless.
SkeeringReal t1_iydw30o wrote
Reply to comment by LilHairdy in [D] ICLR 2023 reviews are out. How was your experience ? by dasayan05
Awh
SkeeringReal t1_iydjn0h wrote
Reply to comment by tfburns in [D] ICLR 2023 reviews are out. How was your experience ? by dasayan05
Is there an update on this for post rebuttal now? What's the new distribution?
SkeeringReal t1_iyd76bw wrote
Reply to [D] I'm at NeurIPS, AMA by ThisIsMyStonerAcount
What does AMA mean?
SkeeringReal t1_ixxbc13 wrote
Reply to comment by dasayan05 in [D] ICLR 2023 reviews are out. How was your experience ? by dasayan05
Thanks 👍
SkeeringReal t1_ixuzpym wrote
What kind of scores do you need to get a spotlight presentation? Eg.g. you get something like 8,8,8,6, all with high confidence.
How are spotlights chosen? I guess they want a diverse set of topics right? Like if there's only one RL paper they may just choose that one?
Anyone here ever been on the committee which decided this stuff?
SkeeringReal t1_ix6mq6i wrote
Reply to comment by wassup369 in [D] ICLR 2023 reviews are out. How was your experience ? by dasayan05
>https://twitter.com/shiqiang_w/status/1588714893309804545?s=20&t=f_DzcCrVtNx9jkEekd0dyQ
That puts you around the 38% mark, so I'd say the chances are not good.
SkeeringReal t1_irqyldf wrote
Reply to [D] how hard is it for an undergrad to publish a first author paper at a reputable conference/journal? by djssoapappskdid
This is absolutely not a hard requirement to get into a PhD!
SkeeringReal t1_j1p73vf wrote
Reply to [D] Are reviewer blacklists actually implemented at ML conferences? by XalosXandrez
Good question