RhiRead

RhiRead t1_j9ewwxo wrote

Have you ever listened to the podcast If Books Could Kill? Highly recommend it, they pick different ‘airport books’ each week (non-fiction fad books, often woo woo themed) and discuss them and the impact they had.

On the episode about The Secret, they say that the book influenced a woman to give up chemotherapy because she really thought that asking the universe to cure her would work.

I guess burning books like this would be harmful at this point because we need to use them as examples of exactly how junk science can be harmful, but i can’t help but think how many people might have been harmed unnecessarily by books like The Secret.

14

RhiRead t1_iycjixe wrote

Terrible book.

The general idea was promising but thats because it’s the plot to Its A Wonderful Life. It lacked any real logic or thought in to the mechanics of the library and the overall tone was just too condescending for me where depression is concerned. I realise it’s based on Matt Haig’s real experiences but it just came across as a bit flat, it lacked any real nuance or understanding in favour of a cheesy happy ending.

2