Devastator1981

Devastator1981 t1_j6f11d7 wrote

• The trails. All of them.

• Distinctive neighborhoods—Anacostia is not like Georgetown which is not like Wharf which is not like NoMa. It’s a GOOD thing to have different neighborhoods with their own vibe, and to have a mix of the historical stuff with new shiny modern things.

0

Devastator1981 t1_j5x6x4w wrote

Re: jail as a deterrent (a bit rambly)

One of the tragedies of criminal justice, is the perverse glorification of getting “locked up” by far too many young kids. So like jail is not a deterrent. I was listening to this podcast on Drink Champs and Bobby Shmurda was basically saying , “eh, jail! All good I know folks there, I’m good, what’s a couple of years”…and yet you also don’t want to indimiscritely ruin people’s lives for weed. But you don’t see C Murder glorifying jail because once you are behind bars for 20, 30 years now that makes you think. It’s not just 2 years then you out and you are almost (from their perspective) better off for it with the cred and connections of jail.

I hope people will see the larger point I’m making—and yes ofcourse 13 years is bullshit.

2

Devastator1981 OP t1_j55md2m wrote

Folks got the wrong impression but it's on me for how I worded the original post. Intent was actually the opposite of "shit testing". It was to demonstrate that there are folks with strong roots to DC (however you want to define it) that are here to stay.

I keep seeing folks will be like "DC is so transient" or "everybody is a transplant" here, suggesting implying some type of shallow or inauthentic collective (or individual) connection to the city. My view is that this is not true.

8

Devastator1981 OP t1_j55kdme wrote

>we can be a little elitist about who qualifies as a DC native! I think you should have a caveat for transplants who've lived here for over ten years, not that I'm one, though! My family moved here during the New Deal to work. I was born in DC, brought up in Cheverly, moved back to DC as a teen.

That's my point, but I didn't communicate it clearly :)

That there are plenty of people with real tangible ties to DC. It's not just all these transients passing through, or that nobody identifies with the place, or that it isn't a real true home to thousands.

1

Devastator1981 OP t1_j557l5q wrote

There's nothing wrong with transplants, hopefully that's not what you got out of my post, happy to edit if that's it the impression.

I'm just pushing back on the "everyone is a transplant here" mantra.

<< Do you call this place home and do you want to make it better? >>

Totally agree.

12

Devastator1981 OP t1_j551c13 wrote

>While I'm definitely not FROM here, I've lived here longer than I've lived anywhere else, and my child was born here.

I don't think you'd be wrong per se if you were out in St. Louis at a conference happy hour and you said you were "from Washington".

Where are you from, what's home?

Where you live?

Where you have lived the longest?

Where you are born?

Where you grew up? (if it's different from where you were born and also where you live)

Where in your heart you identify with?

All of the above? :)

2

Devastator1981 OP t1_j54xbvu wrote

>I would say my friends and acquaintances are about 50/50 native and transplant. But the transplants have almost all been here at least a decade. We’re lifers.

I knew those existed in this city! I was starting to wonder 😉

I think what people mean to say is "a high number [or many] young white-collar professionals in their 20s are transient and often from elsewhere". It's a very specific demographic to which that applies to, and they're often friends with each other and so folks just apply it as a blanket statement. And even that might be too general, it's the Hill/public policy/IR/poli sci crowd even within the white-collar professionals that are disproportionally transient, but to be fair DC has a relatively higher number of this crowd than probably any other city in the US (the world?).

I'm not even being that pedantic, outside of that demographic there's quite a bit of lifers and people here in DC for the long haul!

9