CADOMA
CADOMA t1_j9k5gk1 wrote
Reply to comment by jaydub1001 in Who's the worst landlord in Springfield? by strangemud
I hear this a lot. Rental housing is a business like any other. Owning a house isn't always an option for people. What is the alternative? Do we strip people of their property and hand it to people who often don't want or can't afford it? Tear down all the apartments in the world or force people into an obligation to own a place they might want to leave soon? I think it could be better regulated but it's better than any alternative I've heard, but those alternatives are few and far between because it's easier to tear something down then to build something new.
CADOMA t1_j9ktngp wrote
Reply to comment by jaydub1001 in Who's the worst landlord in Springfield? by strangemud
I love how long this response is without answering the question.
It cost me 10k to replace my HVAC. Let that sink in. That was why I avoided buying a home for years. Who shoulders that cost in your utopia?
I really want to know how the logistics of building an equitable free housing market. Because these are the issuea i came up with in about 5 minutes of thought.
Is maintenance covered in the cost of housing in your world?
Who gets the really nice house's? Is there some sort of lottery were unlucky people get shit? Or are we just talking about building Cabrini Green everywhere.
What happens to all of the existing rental properties? Do we buy them or just steal them from owners?
How do you deal with places like California where the citizens vote time and time again to stop multi home structure construction. The housing market there is garbage because the people won't allow apartments to be built.
Who gets Free housing? Do you have to qualify?
What happens to Airbnb?
I suspect this is why the most progressive countries in the world haven't adopted this concept. It's far better to regulate the rental business. The US does this poorly. Take more control and give it to the renters. Make sure that certain protections are enforced by law. Making it impossible for slumlords to profit or exist.
Also a basic income for those who need it would help retain the power of choice.