Ben_Hocking
Ben_Hocking t1_itzr26c wrote
Reply to comment by houstonyoureaproblem in Cross-examination of a coroner by LadeeAlana
IANAL, but I'm assuming that while you're not allowed to ask leading questions during direct examination, you are allowed to not ask leading questions during cross-examination. If I'm understanding u/thisissuchbsffs correctly, I think that's what she was referring to.
Ben_Hocking t1_itzzh05 wrote
Reply to comment by houstonyoureaproblem in Cross-examination of a coroner by LadeeAlana
I'm not sure how non-leading yes/no questions would screw things up, assuming you knew the answer to the yes/no question ahead of time. (And if you don't, then the leading question might actually be worse, in my non-lawyer opinion.) To use your example, I don't see a significant difference (under cross-examination) between the two questions:
>So not “Did you check the victim’s pulse?” but “You didn’t check the victim’s pulse, did you?”
Again, I recognize that you know more than I do and have vastly more experience in the court than I do*, so I admit ahead of time that I might be missing something.
*My experience is limited to unsuccessfully fighting a traffic ticket when I was a young adult and serving on two juries.