AvailablePresent1113
AvailablePresent1113 t1_j6de88y wrote
Reply to comment by LetWrong1932 in [D] CVPR Reviews are out by banmeyoucoward
Okay, thank you for your information. Do you know what is the minimum score after rebuttal to get accepted? Thanks xD
AvailablePresent1113 t1_j6cnhq4 wrote
Reply to comment by LetWrong1932 in [D] CVPR Reviews are out by banmeyoucoward
Well I previously submitted to ICCV so it's just my guess as ICCV did not have B post rebuttal. So B after rebuttal is still valid?
AvailablePresent1113 t1_j6cf8e9 wrote
Reply to [D] CVPR Reviews are out by banmeyoucoward
I really want to know what is the minimum scores after rebuttal to get accepted? As after rebuttal things should only be A, WA, WR, R, will 3 WA secure acceptance or can 2 WA, 1 WR get any chance?
AvailablePresent1113 t1_jablmv8 wrote
Reply to [D] CVPR Rebuttal scores are out! by ElPelana
What a joke! I have a reviewer clearly champions for rejection and the two other reviews are completely yes-men. The rejecting reviewer did acknowledge some of my rebuttals, but then make some more non-sense excuses just to drag my paper down. The other reviewers just agree with anything he/she said without any clear stance. Seriously, I think there should be rules and restrictions for reviewers to say anything they conveniently want as "marginal"/"incremental"/...