Submitted by jamescookenotthatone t3_11xdorh in todayilearned
With all the environmental things going on, why not put it out?
Maybe, because it has nothing to do at all with anthropogenic climate change?
> The site's name is Mount Wingen but is commonly called Burning Mountain
Nobody knows how it earned the nickname.
Everything in Australia wants to kill you. Even the ground.
Billy Joel was brought in for questioning but continues to deny involvement, authorities say.
He didn't start the fire!
At least the ground in Australia is honest about its intentions.
[deleted]
It would cost way way way too much. Even then probably impossible. We don't control nature.
However, as hot air rises, the burning ground in Australia is perfectly safe.
There is one thing that is not doing that: Volcanoes.
There's something similar going on in the abandoned town of Centralia, Pennsylvania. In the 60s or something the coal mine underneath the town caught on fire, has been on fire since then and everyone moved out. I'm assuming it's impossible to put the fire out.
[deleted]
I’m assuming the downvotes are from people scared of the word anthropogenic
It's reported that his comment on it was "it was always burning, since the world's been turning."
According to the Aborigines it is anthropocentric though...
The Grateful Dead did.
Ask a tween how old a boomer is…
Ask a twink how moldy my bloomers are.
Has anybody considered that this might be the gateway to Hell?
*Highway to hell
i mean you’d probably have to redirect a river into it to stop it
Send in the Emu’s….bbq…..
The local explanation is so blunt, a man fell down a sinkhole. He lit a torch and incinerated himself. No magic sky birds, just a poor unfortunate who warns us to this day of his folly.
Ah, I see Billy subscribes to the 6000 year-old world theory.
Because putting out a fire that rages through a million tiny cracks in the ground requires that you find ALL of those tiny cracks. This is not something science has an answer to yet.
Nah. That's in Turkmenistan
Did you, like, intentionally read around the stuff you didn’t like?
Not everything, especially concerning ancient human societies, has to boil down to “religion bad.” Until fairly recently (in the grand scheme of our existence) religion and the supernatural was how all people alive understood the world.
> The Aborigines named the mountain Wingen, which means 'fire'. Their explanation of the origin of the burning mountain was that one day, a tribesman was lighting a fire on the mountainside when he was carried off deep into the earth by The Evil One. Unable to escape, he used his fire stick to set the mountain alight, so that the smoke might warn others to keep away.
He is literally carried into the mountain by an evil spirit and lights the mountain on fire to warn others of the spirit’s presence. The complete opposite of your understanding.
[removed]
[removed]
[removed]
It could be excavated in advance? Travels at 1m/year. Begin 50 meters down the road..
Did this thousand-years fire punch a hole in Earth's fart shield?
Its a vein of coal in the earth, its not gonna expand beyond the bounds of the coal, its just that short of excavating the ENTIRE thing theres no way to make it stop, and making a pit that big costs a lot of money. That much funding would frankly do more good elsewhere.
Where's Roshi when you need him
Ok I got it, fracking but with... Foam.
1 Government contract pls.
[removed]
[removed]
Foam? Why not seawater? No shortage of salt water any time soon.
2 government contracts, pls.
Also fracking is pretty short-ranged as i understand it, damn inverse square law. If it were that small we could just comb the whole thing with enough people, the problem is that its a lot bigger than that.
My whole yard is coal wash from a nearby mine. Two years ago when the PNW had that really bad summer where it got to 114 degrees we had a fire start in the yard. We got it taken care of and started looking for the source. Using our excavator and some kind of a heat vision thing we dug into a really hot spot underground. Dude, the dirt in the pit we dug was fucking boiling. It's normally a thick black mud out here, but it looked like bubbling black sand. Like I was boiling ink.
I'm not sure what started it, it could have been burning for years and the drout is all that was needed to set the lawn on fire, but it was spooky man.
Is that 1 mile per year or one meter per year?
There’s some long running fires underground along the Colorado Front Range too. They were cited as a possible source for a wild grassland fire that burnt down almost a thousand homes at the end of 2021.
This episode of Bluey is called "Coal Fires".
Bluey-fied picture of a lump of coal...on fire.
I'd recommend sending in an army of Russian 5th graders to put out the fire but they will probably be sent to the front lines in Ukraine here pretty soon =(
Coal is being dug in mines for profit all over. How deep is this burn? It has air. It scorches the earth..
At last: We've identified the source of global warming climate change!
I imagine it would also be incredibly dangerous to even attempt, you're exposing coal thats been burning off of a tiny stream of o2 for ages, to a ton of air all at once.
That's insane. I can't imagine. How long had you lived there before discovering your angry dirt?
18 years! The soil itself is fairly new as far as dirt goes, as the mine was open less than 150 years ago though I don't know the exact date
Because salting the earth is almost as bad as a low, slow fire
Whaaaaaaat?! So fascinating! Did the snow stick in those spots over the years? Oh my gosh I have a million questions.
Oh yeah, i forgot about that. Well eityer way fracking wouldn't work because it covers too small an area.
Oi why don't they just put water on it. Problem?
Yeah the snow had no problem sticking, and we get so much rain the ground gets soaked a long ways down. It had to have been a very recent event, we did burn some wooden construction waste a few months prior but we'd never had a problem like this before so I'm not sure. It's quite a mystery
I get not putting it out (hugely impractical scale), but it's weird that nobody's found a way to monetise it.
Free heat enough to scorch the earth and nobody's come up with a way to make electricity from it?
Coal being dug for profit depends on many things. Ease of access, both in the mining sense (how easy is it to dig a mine, and how safe is the soil around it to prevent subsidence) and the distance to where it is needed. In a remote area, transportation costs might soon exceed mining profits even if it's high grade coal.
All those fire are started by dumbasses who move here thinking theyre fucking les stroud and make a mess of the place
It still contributes to the same issues, even if it's not caused by humans.
The vast amounts of resources needed to even try to put this out probably far outweigh the benefits.
But i don't think it's accurate to say that just because it's not human made it can't haem us.
True. But then there is no coal. Removing the fuel would make it stop burning.
Tbt. I imagine someone would have done it if there was profit to be made. It may drive a sick kind of tourism? I donno. But stopped it can be. Probably not worth it.
Post some pics man! Would love to see it!
What I am saying is, that it is totally irrelevant to current climate change. It doesn't "contribute to the same issues", because natural sources just don't have the same, critical effect, even if you take all of them combined, as anthropogenic climate change.
Dunno what to say to this. That's simply not true.
You can't say that human coal burning contributes to our climate change but coal burning that we didn't cause doesn't contribute.
RYAN STARTED THE FIRE!
That’s why you get a contract to get rid of the salt water you used to get rid of the fire
Oct 23rd, 4004 BC
Fire, fire on the mountain.
Unfortunately I didn't get any pictures :( I was pretty occupied, but I wish I had gotten some
The Centralia, PA mine fire is only 61 y/o. Barely even on the chart! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia,_Pennsylvania
<Serious> How can coal burn underground with no oxygen source?
I remember going there quite some years ago, you could see the path the fire had taken, where the trees had died and the ground had subsided.
Because we can't export it, so no cunt is interested
How does a fire burn underground? Wouldn't lack of oxygen put it out?
What /u/Vlacas12 means is this; There are $X tons of CO2 released naturally. There are $Y tons of CO2 released due to human activity.
$X isn't such a big deal, taken apart from $Y, because nature recycles it. Add in $Y, which is more than nature can make use of, that's a big deal.
Does that makes sense? OP is breaking it down, you're taking a total approach. One can't say either view is wrong.
Fantastic guide.
When I was a kid I used to think the line "trouble in the Suez!" was "trouble in the sewers!" because I was a child and didn't know what the Suez was. Around the same exact time, I walked out into the living room while my mom was watching IT and it was the part where Pennywise was trying to lure Georgie down into the sewer. So I spent an unreasonable amount of time in 1990-'91 thinking there was some epidemic of child-murderers lurking in the sewers.
Thats why its burning for so long its just smoldering if its good material even a small bit can smolder for very long time look up amadou tinder fungus.
found philomena cunk's reddit account
Cracks and crevices in the ground allow air in. Not very much air - the coal is just barely alight, just barely smouldering, like charcoal and a barbeque.
Normally, coal would go out with so little air. However, it's trapped deep underground and the heat can't escape. So, even just smouldering, with the heat being trapped, will keep the fire alight.
Probably slow convection through the soil
Why don't they put it out with a kame hame ha blast?
[removed]
Sounds super efficient, do you think this coal thing has legs? I'm sure there are no drawbacks.
How is it possible that you have 2 million comment karma?
My first job was at a sawmill. They had an area for air drying timber that was previously a dump for sawdust and bark, and it was capped with a metre of fill.
One of my tasks was to take the temperature of the ground around a crack in the fill that had been smoking for ten or so years.
There was no way to put out the fire, but the concern was if it broke through, all the semi-dried timber stacked on top would go up in flames. Plus, the site backed onto the forest, so a fire would be disastrous.
I'll add one more wHy DoNt ThEy JuSt PuT iT oUt to this thread and then my shitty idea that wouldn't work/is impossible followed by waxing poetic about how passionate I am about climate change and then finally put a bow on the whole thing by making an incredibly forced Australia upside down joke.
A lot of coal is burning too, in Montana. If there’s coal, there’s a chance it can catch fire.
The same way you get to Carnegie Hall.
Mapquest.
Australia never ceases to be more terrifying to me.
They used an old pit mine as a dump. Then they set the dump on fire. Fire spread to the coal seam underground.
1m per year, sounds dumb but can’t we just dig a fire break like we do in the tree lines
I don't think that would do it.
It's clearly got its own oxygen source down there and open spaces that aren't braced frequently collapse protecting the front edge of the fire from the burned sections and the unburned sections aren't that permeable to water.
Quantity over quality.
Who says there is no oxygen source?
Who decided to store drying timber on top of smoldering sawdust?
But what about Carnegie Mellon?
Their acceptance rate is about 14%, same as my Reddit comments. You don't get to 2 million karma without taking countless thousands of downvotes.
Actually got the nick name because that's where they used to 420 blaze it
Haha. Similarly my first musical memory was at 3 or 4 years old and it's sitting in the back of my mom's car thinking BJ is singing "Harmonicaaa harmonicaaa."
The tune made sense in my preschool head. :-)
Quality is an oddly subjective thing. The vast majority of my most-upvoted shit is just sorta meh, whereas there are some absolute gems out there that land with a resounding thud and die with three upvotes. I click save on them all the same so I can go back and giggle when I'm bored and/or sad Landlubber.
Grateful Dead wrote a whole song about it
Wonder if you could use the heat to make power somehow
And in ancient times, the the Greco-Roman Ploutonion at Hierapolis.
In the Pacific Northwest?
Because it’ll turn into steam?
>The Aborigines named the mountain Wingen, which means 'fire'.
I'd say they asked the locals but this is probably more of a "great minds think alike" situation. lol
Sooo quantity then?
It's Australia, when they're done they can just tow the saltwater out of the environment.
Yes. That's where Oregon is
I'm not sure what you're surprised at
We probably could but the practicality of it would depend on how deep and wide the vein is. If it's 100m deep and 50m wide it's probably too expensive to dig a suitable trench out to completely cut off the vein. Also, it wouldn't stop the fire, it would just prevent it from spreading any further.
Fuck… American here. 1m a year?? Which M?? Mile? Meter? Milli something 😂??!
Just for that level of dryness to be present in that region. Since it’s a temperate rainforest and everything.
Ah yeah, the rainforest is only in the Olympic peninsula from what I've seen. It gets wet a lot there
Edit: to add we've been at like 80% of our regular water table and in a drought the last few years
Depends on who you ask I guess. I encourage anyone to get out there and try to throw endless comments out and see if it gets you to 2 million. There's some dude out there with like 20-something million comment karma, he's probably the one to ask. I used to be 50th on Earth, now I'm barely scraping top-100. I got banned from my main karma sub six years ago, now I just grab a bit here and there.
Yeah, that’s what everyone thinks, that it rains every day. I assure you, it does not.
Have you looked into whether there is any sort of comeback or cleanup/compensation available from the former mine owners? This doesn’t seem right.
Amazing use of your free time. I wish I had such low standards. I’m rich, but sad. I envy your meaningless karma.
Oh I suspect you're mocking me. Here's a shiny. Cheer up.
I think I thought that but was really more interested in being lazy and wanting to not google how much a meter is in comparison to feet. I know it’s bitchy. It’s enough that I know 3 feet is one yard!
Half of Oregon looks like Arizona. It has scorpions and snakes
We have rainforests and deserts; Ski mountains and hot springs; Volcanoes and cedar groves. Don't judge us by Portland and Seattle.
Didn’t know the first part but snakes aren’t exclusive to desert climates.
Fair enough but hot springs, snowy mountains and volcanoes can be found almost anywhere.
No? I mean, I live on seven acres and 4 of them have this coal wash going down like three feet. I don't think there's anything to do about it, and besides the plants seem to like it. I don't even know if the mining company is active, a logging company runs the hill now.
Catch the steam with a tarp, it condenses and falls back down. Boom you got yourself a self sustaining fire putter outer.
I’m not an engineer or scientist so I can’t say whether that would work or not.
Look at a satellite map of Oregon. Most of the green is concentrated in the Cascadian range of the west. It's mostly desert as you go east.
Dave did, he liked the job security.
Generally they aren't a fan of damp though, unless sea snakes. Should have seen my face when we found a scorpion though, colour me surprised!
Also I recommend the movie even cowgirls get the blues not as good the book obvs but the rock makes an appearance
My ex-bf once tried to convince me that the “eternal flame” was burning because of Jesus
That's in Kansas.
Usually takes a crane to put them out..
You know damn well it'd work, don't steal my idea
That'll be wrong & totally against the ethos of selling more fossil fuel
That’s some twin peaks shit. fascinating!
Actually, I was just being a clown. It wasn’t a serious comment.
So you’re saying It’s above the environment?
every rainforest on earth would like to disagree
We do not get enough average annual rain in most parts of Oregon to be a temperate rainforest by about 10 inches. And even without that, the wooded, foresty areas that everyone thinks of when thinking of oregon are on the northwestern coastal areas. The rest of the state is varying states of grasslands and dessert, and while less poplated, is the larger portion of the state by far.
You are correct. I forgot about the other snakes
They COULD do that to save the environment. OR say fuck it and ignore it.
Wait, which song did you think that was part of?
Just how toxic is your yard? Coal wash is not exactly known as good healthy ground right?
No clue! The plants like it, the grass grows very sugary and none of our animals have like cancer or anything. In fact they usually live their full lifespans, all our dogs get to be ancient and our cats get old as balls too. The horses like the grass so much they get fat and the elk make a point of eating up the yard. All things considered it doesn't seem very toxic!
It was only Partly_Dave's fault.
LucifersLoveEggs t1_jd2hgeb wrote
Holy smoke batman