This is hilarious and stupid at the same time. At least you got to be in the show!

But on a more serious note, you shouldn't have pushed her so much. On the other hand if she already knew it was all just one big South Park routing and it took her 4 years to admit she resented you for even liking it... Well, all I gotta say is part of the blame for that is on her part and it would be silly if she didn't give you a second chance and explained what's bothering her about it.

Long story short... You guys need to communicate better. Best of luck, Fatass!