Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

sedeyus t1_j628voh wrote

Everything David Simon has done has been top quality. Impressive considering even a lot of great television writers (David Milch, Matthew Weiner) have struggled after their shows went off the air to recapture the magic.

19

LordXenu45 t1_j6296ff wrote

No particular order but David Simon, Vince Gilligan, Peter Gould, Craig Mazin, Mike Flanagan, and Trey Parker.

Also Sam Esmail although I've only seen Mr. Robot as far as his work.

11

cheap-thrills2022 t1_j62dyfl wrote

David Chase and David Simon, Aaron Sorkin at his best is brilliant. Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould achieved something magical these past 14 years with BB and BCS.

8

Sitheref0874 t1_j62f5ik wrote

David Milch, at his best, was the best.

J Michael Straczynski. He's niche, comics and sci-fi, but I'd argue that Babylon 5 is one of the great achievements of 90s TV.

From the UK, John Sullivan, who wrote Only Fools and Horses, Linehan, Horowitz keeps churning people pleasing tv, year after year. Is it highest quality? Maybe not. But the consistency is impressive.

6

UmpShow t1_j62hc0d wrote

I'm throwing Rob Thomas out there because Veronica Mars is a gd masterpiece and iZombie is really well written as well.

4

jayz93j t1_j62jr45 wrote

Lindelof hasn’t always written the best movies but he wrote some of Lost while show running and has a writing credit on every episode of The Leftovers.

Plus Watchmen!

8

Khal-Stevo t1_j62jy8m wrote

Matt Weiner wrote 12 episodes of the Sopranos and then created and wrote most of Mad Men. That’s pretty hard to compete with.

Obviously a shoutout to David Simon who’s written multiple incredible pieces of work, but I’d give Weiner the edge

Lot of love for Vince Gilligan as he deserves but if we’re talking strictly about writing he’s probably a notch below those two. In terms of overall maker of television, if his next project lands he’ll easily be the top dog

5

urgasmic t1_j62lofa wrote

I enjoy Robert and Michelle King who wrote The Good Wife, The Good Fight, BrainDead, and Evil.

4

FoMoni t1_j62m93n wrote

David E. Kelly is one of my favourites: Picket Fences, Ally McBeal, The Practice, Boston Legal, Boston Public, Goliath, Mr. Mercedes, Big Little Lies, Big Sky, Big Shot, The Lincoln Lawyer, and many more.

3

warrenmax12 t1_j62nem4 wrote

David Simon, Terrence Winter, David Milch, Aaron Sorkin

2

inkista t1_j62owhi wrote

Dennis Potter. God-level television.

1

pishposhpoppycock t1_j62plwo wrote

Joss Whedon for certain genres, Damon Lindelof, Noah Hawley, Aaron Sorkin, and the 30 Rock writers who wrote any and all of Jenna Maroney's dialogue.

4

Extension-Carry2584 t1_j637i2n wrote

David Simon - David Chase - Jesse Armstrong - Vince Gilligan - Aaron Sorkin

Taylor Sheridan too but I wouldn't put his writing on the same bar with the others

1

blamdin t1_j63cotr wrote

Micheal Schur - The Office, Brooklyn 99

1

SirZapdos t1_j63ozgp wrote

He's got the kind of writing that can be so smooth.

I also got a kick when Rob Thomas of Matchbox 20 was introduced in that one episode of iZombie, he was introduced as "the one, the only Rob Thomas".

2

lorZzeus t1_j6als9k wrote

This post should be upvoted, as I think writers are way more important for a show to be good than any famous and awarded actor.

The writers I consider the best are:
- Jonathan Nolan (Person of Interest, Westworld);
- Joss Whedon (Buffy, Angel, Firefly, Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.);
- Michael Schur (Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Parks and Recreation, The Office (US), The Good Place);
- Damon Lindelof (Lost, The Leftovers, Watchmen);
- David Lynch (Twin Peaks);
- Ronald D. Moore (Battlestar Galactica (2004), For All Mankind, Roswell, Star Trek: DS9);
- Vince Gilligan (Better Call Saul, Breaking Bad, The X-Files);
- David Simon (The Wire, Treme, The Deuce, We Own This City);
- Bryan Fuller (Heroes, Hannibal, Pushing Daisies);
- Russel T. Davies (Doctor Who, Torchwood, It's a Sin);
- Noah Hawley (Fargo, Legion);
- Phoebe Waller-Bridge (Fleabag, Killing Eve);
- Steven Moffat (Doctor Who, Sherlock).

Sorry for the long list.

2

SlightlyJason t1_j6c1zog wrote

tbh. None matter. All the best writers have wrote good and bad shows.

1