This is what I came to say.

Except, high school Joey would have watched with Dawson and talked over it with her cynicism the whole time while Dawson defended it to the death.

Dawson was very idealistic.

Pacey would watch it in secret and love it, and be "mortified" when Joey discovered his secret, bc he let some obscure scene slip into conversation. Pacey had a romantic soul (I remember everything)

But spot on with Jen.

Sorry, in the middle of a rewatch with my 16 year old daughter. 😁