Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

J-ShaZzle t1_izyw3t9 wrote

It's trying to prove that the cargo wasn't that heavy and the weight of the truck was high. Which leads to a false "wow" this truck can move this much and still retain miles before charging.

As with the Ford lightning real world tests prove, towing with an electrical vehicle significantly reduces your miles. I can imagine that if the Tesla semi was max cargo, their claims would have to be significantly lower than what they demonstrated.

As it stands, the E350 cargo van seems like the only sensible electric hauler. It is geared towards short sprints around town and daily charging while home though.

I'm not knocking the idea of electric and towing, but there is a ROI with packing weight into a vehicle and it's ability to get miles. Personally, I think current tech allows for a swap of battery packs or trucks to keep drivers going for the amount of hours they travel. It's not like long haul drivers can just stop and charge midway, let alone the infrastructure needed for pull through overnight charging at rest stops. Logistics and tech are currently holding back electric for long hauling, but any progress is good coupled with, having to start somewhere.

3

PM_ME_C_CODE t1_izz0r60 wrote

Current battery tech limitations are why some people are pushing hydrogen as an alternatives specifically for long haul trucking.

Even after taking things like embrittlement and leakage into account, it's probably the best liquid fuel alternative until we can improve battery/capacitor tech to the point it's a non-issue.

Improving battery tech will take time.

We can start mounting hydrogen fuel cells for an all-electric drive-train today.

"But hydrogen is actually grey hydrogen! Why do you hate da urth?"

Fuck you. EV electricty isn't 100% clean either and you're letting theoretical perfection (not even real perfection, you fucking wankers) be the enemy of improvement.

Heavy batteries on big-rigs is a bad idea.

Elon should have been laughed off of the stage when he first unveiled these fucking piece of shit trucks.

2

p38fln t1_j04ykv9 wrote

The infrastructure needed is completely insane, I think Tesla said it would take 2kwh per mile...can you imagine recharging 100 trucks at once after all of them did a 500 mile drive, all at the same truck stop? You get 10 hours to do it before they have to be rolling again. That's a crazy amount of power being sucked in all at once.

1