Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

szypty t1_j75zwhf wrote

The effort needed to fabricate all the evidence to the contrary would be far too ridiculous for consideration.

The fossil record alone would require a borderline omnipotent entity to fake. And yeah, there are some ever shrinking gaps in it but trying to fit the entire "humans are actually from Mars" theory in it is beyond absurd.

And then you have the mitochondrial DNA and other factors which allowed us to map the Tree of Life of all known organism, a model thwt we fit into quite well.

9

Loose-Addition-5730 t1_j76056c wrote

The idea that Mars at some point in it’s existence may have harboured life is a valid one. When you go from there and make the assumptions in your post, there is no evidence to support that.

7

SardonicKaren t1_j760lyn wrote

You have a great future as a sci-fi fantasy writer...get cracking!

6

5wiatowid t1_j7612le wrote

Olympus Mons was named in 1970s so this reasoning is dumb.

Humanity as spawn of ancient astronauts from mars or other planets is old concept, romantic but no evidence supporting it.

Look up anthropogenesis and stop watching "ancient aliens"

1

daikatana t1_j761oav wrote

Absolutely not. We have billions of years of genetic heritage on this planet. If we were Martians then we would, at the very least, not fit into the genetic landscape on Earth, if not have a completely different biology.

3

Theometer1 t1_j762i8i wrote

Evolution alone disproves this theory, this some ancient aliens stuff right here.

1

JacqueMorrison t1_j762m4s wrote

Look at it this way. The sun was colder and dimmer and is getting hotter and brighter. Venus might have been the first place where life emerged in the solar system. Any evidence was likely destroyed when the atmosphere evaporated the rocks on the surface. Mars would actually be more habitable/warmer now, it it didn’t lose its magnetic sphere/atmosphere.

1

JesusChrist-Jr t1_j7631ow wrote

Based on the fact that we have fossil records and now understand genetics to the point that we can prove the path of evolution that led to humans and that all creatures on earth share a single-celled ancestor, I don't think it's reasonable to think that humans originated in something close to our current form off-planet. However, the idea of panspermia is interesting, that life on earth could've been seeded by building blocks that arrived via meteorite (or were intentionally placed by an intelligent alien species.) One of the questions that comes up when speculating on how common life is in the universe is that, as far as we can tell, life only arose on earth once. All life that exists and has ever existed, that we know of, share one common ancestor. If life were common where conditions were suitable, it seems we would've likely found evidence for multiple instances of genesis of life here on earth. Perhaps our planet was intentionally seeded with the right building blocks for life to form, or even with a cocktail of ingredients tailored to conditions on earth.

There are other smaller critiques that can be made toward your thought experiment, such as any craft that could crash into the earth with enough force to cause the mass extinction of the dinosaurs, yet remain structurally sound enough to allow for even a few of its passengers to survive, likely would be fairly easy to detect. Further, we have found evidence in the geological record that supports a meteorite coinciding with that mass extinction, in the form of a worldwide deposit of iridium from the meteorite as it burned on atmospheric entry (iridium is either extremely rare or non-existent naturally on earth.)

The stories in various cultures of gods with seemingly magic powers, or flying machines, or many other things that can be explained by technology rather than magic today is interesting, and I don't think it's entirely impossible that some could have been ancient aliens or members of some civilization that was technologically advanced far beyond our comprehension at the time, but popular culture and the "crank" nature of some of these ideas' most vocal proponents has understandably put most people with a professional reputation to protect off of these ideas. It's interesting to ponder, but I doubt we'll ever see any solid proof of any of it.

Some movies have touched on these ideas, Prometheus opened with a scene of an alien forerunner intentionally seeding a barren, early earth with the precursors to life. Mission to Mars also may be of interest to you, but I won't go into detail to avoid late-story spoilers. One of the Predator movies also showed a flashback to an earlier time when they visited earth and were received as gods. A relatively small part of the movie, but still cool to see it played out on screen. I'm sure there are many more sci-fi stories that explore these ideas, but those are a few relatively recent movies that come to mind that you may enjoy, even just for curiosity's sake.

1

SpartanJack17 t1_j7636i1 wrote

>What if Mount Olympus, and many other locations that we have only heard or read about actually existed?

Mount Olympus is a real mountain in Greece LMAO.

1

SpartanJack17 t1_j7637o6 wrote

Hello u/KainGreyson, your submission "Mars:The Lost Home" has been removed from r/space because:

  • Such questions should be asked in the "All space questions" thread stickied at the top of the sub.

Please read the rules in the sidebar and check r/space for duplicate submissions before posting. If you have any questions about this removal please message the r/space moderators. Thank you.

1