Tanglemix t1_irkinh2 wrote
Reply to comment by wen_mars in We are in the midst of the biggest technological revolution in history and people have no idea by DriftingKing
I've seen people using very simple sketches as prompts which work ok to get fairly simple compositions that try to match the sketch. I haven't yet seen examples where the inital sketch is more sophisicated and includes things like specific lighting or perspective foreshortening- but you may be right that some hybrid input of human plus AI may evolve in the future- it's an interesting idea.
I'm less convinced on the AGI side. At present AI Art is a kind of trick- it looks impressive but is less than it seems to be because the AI has no actual understanding of the things it is depicting- it deals in patterns of pixels that correlate to word combinations- it has no idea that these patterns represent volumes in 3D space that have surface material qualities that interact with the light sources in the scene.
To be a truly viable substitute for human artists AI would have to move beyond 2D and be able to understand that the scenes it generates are abstractions from a 3 Dimensional reality.
I can at least imagine a sort of autonomous version of Blender or 3D Max that in response to a prompt then builds a complete 3D scene, including geometric objects, textures, materials, light sources and volumetric effects like mist and ariel perspective- and from this render 2D images from any perspective desired.
The thing I find harder to imagine is how such a system could conjure 3D representations of imaginary objects and scenes that do not exist- where would the training data come from to make this possible?
wen_mars t1_irkunsa wrote
I don't know where they source the training data from but we can already see early examples of AI that can generate 3D models from 2D input.
Tanglemix t1_irp3vk9 wrote
I have seen those and they are amazing-but seem to rely on multiple images of the same existing object to generatethe 3D model
The real trick would be to create a convincing 3D model from a single image of something that did not exist- something imaginary.
If an AI were able to do this it would be replicating what a human concept artist might do when presented with a single sketch as a starting point.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments