Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Zoesan t1_iu3xrzv wrote

Reply to comment by SovArya in Exercise linked with increased longevity. Compared with just two minutes of vigorous activity per week, 15 minutes was associated with an 18% lower risk of death and a 15% lower likelihood of cardiovascular disease, while 12 minutes was associated with a 17% reduced risk of cancer by Wagamaga

Run for 3x 15 minutes per week and cut your calories by 20%

Congrats, you just got gifted 15 years of life

93

SovArya t1_iu3xxmc wrote

1 minute intense knee ups a day. And you'll improve your health for the rest of your life.

19

EastvsWest t1_iu4jsqj wrote

But like walking, people shouldn't be aiming for the literal bare minimum of effort. Build muscle while getting lean as you age is your goal.

20

triffid_boy t1_iu5oer1 wrote

While I agree with you in principle and practice, you've now added your own stuff on top. In doing so you are perfectly demonstrating why information like this doesnt get communicated or gets lost. People add their own stuff to the proven facts all the time.

Keep it simple. A little bit of intense exercise adds up to good health gains. If People take this up they might see improvements and look to make more gains through other means like weights.

29

EastvsWest t1_iu8yo5z wrote

Intense exercise that doesn't promote muscle growth isn't ideal. Having muscles into your 40s,50s,60s etc is how you stay mobile and fit far into your late life. It's also how you prevent the majority of naturally occurring pain from joints, back pain, knee pain.

There's enough science for people who want more than the minimum. Listen to Andrew Huberman, David Sinclair or Peter Attia if you want the latest in general health. Cardio is very important but you want both and I would recommend starting with muscle promoting exercises first then everything else. That is the fountain of youth along with sleep, diet (mediterranean) and close bonds with family/friends, sense of purpose and belonging.

0

triffid_boy t1_iu922eo wrote

Like I said, I agree with you, and do exactly this.

But that's not the point. bombarding People who aren't already active with a big to do list as a way to get fit is a bad idea. Start with little and often with consistency and build from there.

Your attitude will turn people away from a really important realisation.

2

SFXBTPD t1_iu51btx wrote

I need to buy a pull up bar. Best budget gym you can get

4

SovArya t1_iu55y68 wrote

Yes. Pull ups, push ups, duck walk, knee ups for the intensive and fast 1 min.

3

elchalupe t1_iu59u7k wrote

Don't even have to run. Just doing 3 x 15 minutes of elevated or fast pace walking can bring enormous benefits.

1

eldenrim t1_iu7wj9i wrote

The calorie one isn't as generic though, right? I'm borderline underweight and sometimes move towards a comfortable middle between underweight and overweight so that'd just lead to issues I feel like.

1

Zoesan t1_iu8zqd1 wrote

You're a small minority. Two thirds of the US are overweight or obese. Underweight people make up around ~1.5% of the US population.

1

eldenrim t1_iu9r8gc wrote

Just to clarify, I was confirming my current understanding which is that doing exercise is essentially always better than a sedentary lifestyle, whereas losing 20% of calories is only relevant to people who are consuming more than they need or who are an unhealthy weight. Which like you said, is the majority of the US (and other countries too).

Although your response does imply that is the case, it's still important to differentiate near-universal advice from majority-applicable advice if someone is unsure.

2