Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

chrisdh79 OP t1_j85bnz0 wrote

From the article: In the study, 112 healthy volunteers between the ages of 18 and 40 took part. Their guilt was measured at the beginning using questionnaires including the state shame and guilt scale (SSGS). This questionnaire asks people whether they feel remorse or bad about something they’ve done. Next, the participants did an exercise intended to make them feel more guilty. The exercise involved writing a story about a time they had treated someone they loved unfairly.

The participants were then divided into three groups. One group received a “deceptive placebo”: a blue pill they were told was a real drug. Specifically, they were told that the pill contained phytopharmacon, a substance designed to reduce the feeling of guilt by making whoever took it feel calmer.

Another group received an “open-label placebo” – the same blue pill, but this group was told it was a placebo. They were told that placebos benefit many people through mind-body self-healing mechanisms.

The third group did not receive any treatment at all. This was the “control” group.

After getting the treatment, the guilty feelings were measured using the same questionnaires to see whether the deceptive placebo or open-label placebo was more effective than no treatment.

47

bear_sees_the_car t1_j86zlcl wrote

The exercise is the problem: this is literally how you work through any uncomfortable feelings. You share them in any form and this is how people get relief.

26

xilec714 t1_j87vguv wrote

I agree, but it looks like the placebo group were more positively affected than the control group, who also went through that part.

18

Archy99 t1_j8a9ppn wrote

Questionnaire-based studies like this are of low scientific quality and do not actually control for response biases (Including Hawthorne effect) due to impossibility of blinding. It is quite possible the effect is just a change in questionnaire answering behaviour and not an actual reduction in guilt.

A more robust methodology would to objectively measure effect of guilt on real world behaviours.

3