Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

zero0n3 t1_j7y4jbb wrote

Except you then don’t know if it was actually outdoors that led to this or say the nutrient mix lacking some ingredient in the indoor mix.

It’s useless data.

3

epelle9 t1_j7y5ia4 wrote

Well, no studies are perfect, but if thats the soil they are grown when sold, it makes sense to compare them that way, and is definitely useful data.

1

Mcdiglingdunker t1_j7z5igo wrote

Then those differences should be explicitly pointed out in the materials and methods as well as how they affect the results in the discussion.

There are a lot of proprietary soil mixes and nutrient/fertilizer regimes. Without this knowledge it is impossible for other groups to repeat this work. As such, the data has some use but is lacking enough detail to be less than definite.

2