Since we're going fantasy, I'll call up a few from the past:

Soup: Lobster Bisque from now gone Zuppa
Starter: The Perfect Egg from now defunct Dutch and Co
Main: Tuna and Osso Buco from now shuttered Mamma Zu
Dessert: I'm not a big dessert guy, so insert your favorite here

Man I miss some former great RVA spots.