Submitted by arikdondi t3_10ds8j9 in philosophy
Mustelafan t1_j4t2h14 wrote
Reply to comment by Impossible_Hunter_39 in On Being a Little God – The “Little Gods” Argument Against Free Will by arikdondi
>They word”my” comes from the Sanskrit word “Maya”
Source? I'm seeing that the word "my" comes from proto-Germanic mīnaz (meaning "my") which itself comes from proto-Indo-European méynos (also meaning "my"). PIE predates the Sanskrit language so it doesn't seem there's a shared etymology at all.
Which is pretty much what I expected. The idea that a "myself" could exist is a more intuitive and basic assumption than that "myself" is illusionary; it would make no sense for this equally basic word to stem from such a philosophical perspective. Not that English borrows much directly from Sanskrit anyway. It sounds like someone is trying to push the idea that our 'wiser' ancestors 'knew' the self was illusory through this bad folk etymology. On the contrary I'm pretty sure most of our ancestors would've had a very strong sense of self lol
Impossible_Hunter_39 t1_j4u7nzb wrote
Not sure what you’re saying here. And Sanskrit is the mother language of all. I’ll try to read your thoughtful words when I’m not so tired. Thx for a very thoughtful note.
TrueBeluga t1_j5aj2r7 wrote
Sanskrit is not the mother language of all other languages. There are many languages that predate it and had already branched off before it existed.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments