Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

NobleOceanAlleyCat t1_itr54u7 wrote

My guess is that Singer knows he’d alienate these billionaires if he came off as too socialist. Given his pessimism about systemic political change, he probably sees the choice as between:

(A) Billionaires donate large sums of money to aid organizations to help worst off + No systemic political change

Vs

(B) Billionaires don’t donate their money + No systemic political change.

Perhaps his pessimism is unwarranted and he should reject both (A) and (B) as the only options. But until he’s convinced of another option, (A) is obviously the better choice, and it’s the choice that Singer is making, by not being too critical of billionaires.

4

ddrcrono t1_ittxzbm wrote

Given this he could also choose a more neutral or mildly critical approach. That would also be a better focus for an article critiquing him here.

1