Submitted by ADefiniteDescription t3_122l5st in philosophy
MrCW64 t1_jdur9ac wrote
Reply to comment by N0_IDEA5 in Examining what makes a life worth living according to the ancient philosophers by ADefiniteDescription
You're assuming that the function of that humans life is being limited by their disability.
e.g. can you really appreciate the need for compassion in life if you've never experienced the need for it yourself?
N0_IDEA5 t1_jduszv4 wrote
Yes that would more or less be the assumption. The function that was likely being referred to in the article was rational thinking. And some people with mental disabilities are impaired or sometimes unable to rational think, and likely they would say that it is not a life worth living. For me I feels that is incorrect, however I do know this idea of there theory is to exclude certain people from having a life worth living, so maybe that exclusion is ideal for them. Or maybe they can just set the bar of rational thinking super low and include these mental disabled as fulfilling there function.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments