Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Mysunsai t1_j6ln6ht wrote

Reply to comment by nbny90 in FreeTaxUSA Says I Owe $3K in federal taxes. I NEVER owe & always get a refund. Please HELP! by nbny90

Just read the instructions for the W4.

If you put married filing jointly, your employer withholds as if you have $25k standard deduction, $20k at 10%, $60k at 12%, etc. Which is correct, those are the tax brackets for married filing jointly.

But if you have multiple jobs (eg both you and your wife work), then combined between your jobs your withholding looks like you have $50k of standard deduction, $40k at 10%, etc. So you massively underwithhold.

The solution is to follow the instructions in step 2 for multiple jobs. (Or alternatively, you could both select single instead of married filing jointly).

5

nbny90 OP t1_j6lnu2r wrote

Follow up questions...

  1. Can we change status back to "single", even though we're married?
  2. When filing taxes next year, do I enter our filing status as "single"? Or "married, filing jointly"?

Thank you so so much for making this easy for me to understand.

2

Ghost_of_JFK t1_j6lojtm wrote

You can change your W-4 to single to increase your withholding. Doesn’t matter if you are married or not. This is basically just a way to tell your employer what to withhold.

When filing taxes you will still go with married, filing jointly (or married filing separately in rare cases).

9

scherster t1_j6mp4ju wrote

You can also just add an amount to be withheld from each check. I think that's easier than messing around with entries on the W4.

1