Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

SpiritualQuokka t1_iy7ifqa wrote

I think you're vastly over-estimating how much impact the small number of people who max their IRAs on January 1st have compared to investors overall. Consider that many, if not most IRA users do not max them on January 1st and that the people with the most to invest put way more than $6k into the stock market annually, and again, usually monthly, not all on January 1st.

25

whisky_in_your_water t1_iy8a6sf wrote

Yup, I do it monthly (will probably change to biweekly next year) so my budget is consistent month to month. If I invested everything on Jan 1, that means I either had $6.5k sitting in cash (not great) or I'm raiding my e-fund (not an emergency). In my case, it's double since my wife and I both max our IRAs.

I try to keep my cash amount as low as I can, so I have automatic investments to each of my accounts. I try to keep my HSA, 401k, IRA, and taxable brokerage investments consistent month to month so I don't need to think about it. If I use my e-fund, I just pause or reduce those automatic investments until it's refilled.

I find the less I think about it, the better off I am.

4

kveggie1 t1_iy7p9s6 wrote

Nope. The impact of that is so small; the market would not feel the difference.

Same for people taking (selling stocks/bonds) for meet their RMD requirements; meaning prices would go down. They do not.

If you are thinking long-term and the market will go up over time, it does not matter when you invest a lump sum.

4

lucky_ducker t1_iy8doyg wrote

Of the average daily volume of stocks traded, retail investors account for around 1%. Not even a drop in the bucket. Large, institutional traders account for nearly all of trading volume.

3

SpeakerClassic4418 t1_iy7j30h wrote

I was more wondering if we will have a decent drop end of this year for loss harvesting. Seems like a lot of people have down positions, may want to sell, book the loss and reallocate

1

zoolover1234 t1_iy7mxxa wrote

No need to wonder, it is true. Not only for loss harvesting, but also for cashing out profit for vacation or shopping, etc. if you check the volume over time for Dec, there is pattern.

However, the volume is not big enough to make any major changes, usually.

3

nolesrule t1_iy80qb6 wrote

I harvest losses when I have them. Why wait till the end of the year when losses you had earlier might be gone?

2