Submitted by Darkly_Gathers t3_y37ioe in nosleep

Drizzle taps lightly on the leaves all around us, the smell of pine rich in the air as we creep through the undergrowth, my Grandad and I.

I run my tongue along my teeth, focusing. I raise the rifle a little higher. A Nosler. A way higher quality weapon than I should be using, the thing is wasted on me. I’m an appalling hunter.

…I’m not even sure if I agree with it, to be honest. Hunting, I mean. Ethically speaking.

I mean, my Grandad and I eat basically everything we kill and, to be honest, I don’t kill a whole lot. I send many of my shots deliberately wide.

I just do this to hang out with him, really. He’s a fascinating man, and the guy likes taking me out into the woods, so. I just go along with it, it’s fine. It’s good quality-time that I’m lucky to have.

But we’re stalking a pair of deer right now. Big things as well. I’m pretty sure the creatures know we’re here, but, you can get surprising close provided you don’t actually give off any sign that you’re tryna shoot them.

“Stay low Robbie”, he murmurs through the side of his mouth. “Move to your right past the bush, then it’s a clean shot. Take it when ready”.

I like my name. Named after the man beside me, as it happens. Robert. He being Robert I, and me of course, Robert II.

I nod and creep into position, taking careful aim as instructed.

I see a thumbs up in the corner of my eye, and I shoot.

…I miss.

The sound ricochets around the forest and birds burst from a nearby tree, shooting up towards the sky. The deer wheel round in a panic and make to leave.

“Godammnit” my Grandad mutters and raises up from behind the bush, bringing his rifle with him and firing off a quick shot.

My ego is somewhat relieved by the fact that he misses too, and we both watch as the deer disappear into the undergrowth and shadow of the forest.

The man lowers his weapon and looks at me. I do the same and give him a shrug.

We hold eye contact for a second, then, he breaks with a chuckle, shaking his head. “Damnit Robbie, every time I think I’ve taught you something you manage to pull off some magnificent blunder just like that”.

“Hey, well, you know what they say- you shouldn’t judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree”.

“I ain’t judging you on your tree-climbing ability. You’re my Grandson. I’m judging you on your ability to swim, fishie”.

I point to the shattered branch my Grandad caused when he fired his shot. “I truly am learning from the best”.

“Bastard”, he snorts with a laugh, thumping me on the chest. “Come on, let’s track ‘em. Plenty daylight left”.

We push around the bush and head through the little clearing, stepping over a fallen log and making to follow the route the deer both took, but my Grandad suddenly stops and holds up his hand with his head cocked to the side.

I pause likewise, waiting, holding my breath and listening intently.

My ears hone in on the sound of rustling foliage and snapping twigs. It grows louder, heading towards us, in the exact direction the deer were running from.

“Jesus”, my Grandad grunts, “they’re coming back this way. They’ll have seen a-” but he is cut off by the sudden emergence of the deer through the bushes ahead. Rushing right at us from the green, gloomy shade.

“Shit!” I shout out loud in a panic. The deer make no attempt to run around us in the slightest and run instead directly towards our position. I raise the rifle and take rapid, shaky aim.

“Damnit Steve, DOWN!” Grandad shouts, grabbing me by the sleeve and hauling me to the forest floor, back behind the log.

…Steve?

The air escapes me as I crash with my Grandad down to the ground, and the deer jump right over us.

My Grandad instantly takes position, cocking and aiming his own rifle over the top of the log, deathly focused.

“Something will have made ‘em run like that. They’ll have seen a wolf, or a bear”.

“A wolf? A bear?”

“I’d be surprised to see either, at this time of day. But as I said. Something made them run”.

My Grandad remains cool and composed, the barrel of the rifle fixed on the damaged woodland ahead and along the deer’s path.

I stick close, watching out in all directions in case we are approached from the side, gun cocked and heart pounding.

…But.. nothing comes.

We wait for a tension-laden minute, then another, muscles aching with the stress of simply holding ourselves in pre-emptive positions, but as I said, nothing else comes towards us.

My Grandad cautiously gets to his feet. “Weird”, he mutters. “We’d better move on out of here. Come on, stay alert, but let’s go”.

I nod in reply and together we make a swift but carefully exit from the little grove, heading back through the woods and retracing our steps.

After what I hope is something of a safe distance, I ask my Grandad a question. “Why’d you call me Steve, back then?”

“Eh?”

“When the deer were coming at me, you called me Steve. You said ‘Steve get down’”.

“Huh, is that so”, my Grandad asks, scratching his chin. “I don’t know. You know Steve though, right? Old friend of mine. I swear I’ve mentioned him before”.

I consider. “Uh… yeah, maybe. Once or twice”.

Grandad shakes his head. “I’ve definitely talked about him more than that. You probably weren’t listening”. He sighs. “It was just the moment, I suppose. The way you were standing, the deer coming right at you, raising your gun… What would have happened if you’d shot one, eh? It would have gone right down and knocked you out with it”.

“I don’t know, it wasn’t all that big-”

“It was bigger than you’re giving it credit for. And at that speed? Would have flattened you. It’s what I told Steve, all those years ago, he did the exact same thing, the idiot”.

“What’s he up to these days?”

My Grandad does not reply. He only looks out into the depths of the forest. We’re atop a high hill, and the trees give way to a view across a deep, green valley. The sky is gray overhead.

The man tuts and shakes his head. “Steve… Steve isn’t around much anymore”.

“Oh, sorry. He’s not… he’s not dead, is he?”

My Grandad grimaces. “I don’t know, exactly”.

“You don’t know?”

“Look, just drop it kid. A story for another day. Let’s just get back to the campsite. Cook that rabbit we caught earlier”.

He pauses, putting out a hand, and I stop at once, following his line of sight.

I hadn’t even spotted it, but it chills my blood to see it now. Gives me the shivers even remembering.

We stand only a few feet away from a deer. It’s one of the same deer as before, I’m sure of it. Neither of us had spotted it because the thing is standing entirely still. Like a statue. A taxidermy, almost.

“The hell?” Grandad whispers, staring at the creature in surprise. He squints and then leans over to me. “It’s breathin’ though only barely. Look down there at its chest”.

I do so, taking the spectacle in. The deer has one hooved foot placed against the trunk of a tree, which in itself is quite curious already… but the animal does not move, even slightly. It does not blink.

“Hey”, my Grandad barks, then louder: “Hey!” he claps his hands, but the deer does not react.

Then, in time with a sudden flurry of water from the rain-soaked leaves above us, the deer slowly turns its head. All the way around, until it is staring at my Grandad and myself, one eye on each.

My stomach drops, though I am unsure as to why. The deer is… I don’t know. Something is wrong.

“The thing must be sick”, my Grandad murmurs. “We’ll take a different route back, go wide of this creature. We’re too close already as it is”

“Yeah”, I mumble, and the two of us edge away and through the undergrowth, taking a new direction as the deer watches us go, deathly-silent.

I shiver as it at last passes out of sight, lost behind us to the watery green shadows of the forest.

​

*

​

Later that night, after returning to camp and preparing and eating our catch, I bid my Grandad goodnight and crawl into my tent, zipping the flaps up after me.

I fumble round in the near-darkness for a while, my lamp casting intense, black shadows out in all directions as I shift it from place to place, trying to work my way into my sleeping bag.

It doesn’t feel particularly cold at the moment, but, the temperature has the potential to suddenly drop at any given minute, and I don’t want to wake up frozen solid at 3am.

…As it happens, I don’t. I awaken at 3:15; not frozen, but slick with sweat.

Roused from a dreamless slumber, my ears prick up at the sound of rustling and snuffling outside.

Right by my tent.

​

I hold my breath and grit my teeth.

​

It’s this fear of the unknown that gets me. It’s probably just a rabbit, or a hare.

…But the possibility that it could be something larger, something more dangerous, is impossible to ignore.

For some reason my mind does not go to an image of a bear, or a mountain lion, or anything like that.

It goes to the deer. Frozen in place. Eyes unblinking, head turning as it watches my Grandad and I pass by.

Something presses up against the tent, right by my head.

I wince and stare at the bulging material through the darkness. I try not to think about the fact that I am separated by the beasts of the forest by a pair of what are effectively thin, flimsy sheets of fabric.

Just ignore it, I tell myself. Ignore it and it’ll go away.

I quietly roll over and scrunch up my eyes, determined to be a man and to not get frightened by the presence of some raccoon or squirrel.

The creature sniffles some more.

Rustling about in the grass, in the dark.

​

My heart rate increases as I hear the thing pawing against the tent’s outer lining.

…And then, for a second, it stops entirely, and to my horror I hear my Grandad’s voice.

​

“It’s breathin’ though only barely”.

​

The sentence comes crisp and sharp through the general murmur and backing breeze of the forest.

The sentence is entirely devoid of cadence. As if read from a book by someone who has never known English.

Look down there at its chest”, says the voice.

​

Fuck.

FUCK.

​

Panicking now, I do not know what I am supposed to do. It’s my Grandad outside, playing a prank on me. It has to be. It MUST be, because there is literally no other explanation that makes sense.

Regardless of the fact that this is entirely out of character. Regardless of the fact that I have never heard the man speak in such a way, even in humor, in his entire life.

He must be sleep-walking. That’s it.

My explosive heartrate cools just a little.

That’s it. It’s the only possible explanation that makes sense.

And if that’s the case, then, I can’t just leave him to wander around outside.

Despite my fear, I gently ease my way out of my sleeping bag. You might think me an idiot, but, if my Grandad is wondering around in the woods in a daze he could get lost, or seriously hurt. So I push aside my irrational terror, and with a shaking hand I reach for the zip, pulling it open with a noise that is far too loud for comfort.

Fuck it. In for a penny, in for a pound.

I yank the zip open, and then the next, and push my head out into the night, the cool air washing across my face as I raise the lantern to cast away the darkness.

​

…What I see, is nothing.

​

I jump outside of the tent, staring, lifting the lantern as the light falls across the long grasses and the nearby trees. We’re still on the ridge of the valley, but the valley itself is shrouded in darkness. A small section of visible moon illuminates the very tips of the trees in silver, but I am too pre-occupied to properly appreciate the natural beauty for now. I pace around the tent in a circle and see no evidence of my grandfather.

“Grandad?” I hiss out into the night, turning and raising the lantern up high.

…Still, nothing.

Something chirps softly from between the branches of the deep woods.

I turn to face it with throat dry, but the trees give away no secrets.

I cross the grass and crouch down by my Grandad’s tent. The zip remains closed.

“Grandad?” I whisper, to no response. I try again, a little louder. “Grandad?

I hear a groan and a grumble from inside.

“Huh?” I hear him mutter, then, “the hell?”

“Grandad are you good?”

“Of course I’m good, what’s the matter with you?”

“Alright… Uh, nothing. See you tomorrow”.

He murmurs something under his breath and I hear the rustle of his sleeping bag as he rolls over. I stand up straight and stare out into the night.

​

For a second time, that chirping sound rings out from the branches, and I make a hasty return to my tent, zipping the thing up tight and secure, shivering as I try to force myself back to sleep.

​

It takes a long time, and I do not recall drifting off. My dreams are disturbing, and are largely comprised of the discovery that something crept into my tent, dream-distorted and warped into an impossible size. My dream-self scrambles around from place to place as a nightmare slithers and swims through the shadows like water.

It is a welcome relief when I awake safe and sound, to the faded glare of tent-filtered, morning sunlight shining into my face.

“Ugh”, I mutter, sitting up straight and groggily rubbing my eyes.

For a second or two the reality of last night blurs into the dreams, but as I remember the truth, that bitterly familiar anxiety settles back in. I clamber out of the tent into the warming morning air to find my Grandad washing his face in a pot of water.

“Mornin’” he grunts. “How you feel this morning?”

“Not great, to be honest”, I reply. “You were sleep-walking last night”.

“Eh?” Grandad glances up at me but continues with his routine. “No, I don’t sleepwalk”.

“You were mumbling nonsense and bashing into my tent at like 3am”, I tell him. “I came to check on you but you… you must have just gone back to bed”.

My Grandad pauses and looks right at me. “So that did happen then. Your disturbing me. Thought I might have dreamt it”. He stands up and scratches his jaw. “Tell me exactly what happened”.

I relay the story, and my Grandad remains silent until its end. Slightly paled he looks around at our surroundings, and down into the valley.

“I fuckin’ knew it”, he mutters, almost imperceptibly. “It’s the same place. The exact same place”.

“What?” I ask him. “What do you mean?”

“I came here with- with Steve, once. I knew I’d been here before. I thought I’d picked the location pretty randomly, but, I guess my subconscious had other ideas”.

“Grandad I don’t know what the hell you’re talking about”.

He stares out over the valley and I follow his gaze. We watch as a small flock of dark birds flutters around in a circle above the trees.

Again… and again… and again…

​

Around and around they go.

​

He turns to look straight at me, his expression grim. Perhaps even… afraid, a little. And this unsettles me deeply. Nothing is supposed to scare that man.

“Pack up, Robbie. Make it good, and be quick. We’re out of here”.

In another atmosphere I might have questioned him, but the vibe is clear. I do as he says at once and in silence, we quickly pack away our gear, loading up our backpacks with constant furtive glances to the trees.

The forest has dried somewhat since yesterday’s rain, but the sky overhead is still a swirl of gray. We set out beneath its gloom, all trace of our modest campsite thoroughly erased.

​

My Grandad’s pace is a little faster than normal. Bracken and pine needles are crunched underfoot as he strides through the woodlands. He clenches his rifle a little tighter, too.

I break the tension.

“Grandad what the hell is going on? What aren’t you telling me?”

“I was an idiot once before”, Grandad replies, as a breeze whistles its way through the boughs of the trees. “And I lost a good friend. I won’t let the same thing happen to you”.

We push through the bushes and pass by a large pond, surrounded by thick, tangled weeds. I glance over to the water.

The water is a grim gray-green and covered in a curious, floating moss. The surface is broken by the heads of three deer, standing perfectly still. The entirety of their bodies below the necks are submerged, and they stare at us as we pass them by.

On another day I might have found the sight quite comical, but right now I feel nothing but cold, biting fear.

One of the deer rises up from the water, rippling it quietly, rearing up onto its hind legs, and my Grandad grabs my sleeve and hauls me along.

“Don’t stop moving. We’re getting out of here. Just keep going, Robbie”.

Our steps become faster, our breathing a little more labored.

The trees rush by, branches scratch at my arms and my face. We push out into a clearing, and my Grandad skids to an immediate halt.

“What is it?” I ask, panting.

​

Something moves in the shadows of the trees, shifting between the branches at the clearing’s opposite side.

The hair at the back of my neck bristles and I instinctively raise the rifle.

The sounds of the birds and the breeze fade away, and the air itself seems to darken as the shifting shadow ahead draws closer.

It is difficult, near-impossible to make out its exact shape through the layers of branch and foliage… But I swear I can see a rough, vaguely humanoid silhouette amongst the shadows and the dark, green-blown blur.

​

Did you come back for me, Robert?” whispers a voice.

​

My muscles tense up in reaction to my name.

Is it my name it speaks... or, my Grandad’s?

My Grandad sucks some air in through his teeth. He begins to carefully sidestep his way round the clearing, and I copy his movements.

​

You wouldn’t leave me behind again… would you?”

​

The voice is not dissimilar to the one I heard last night. It is different, sure, but the cadence, or lack thereof, is much the same.

​

My Grandad raises the rifle, cocks it… but he does not fire.

“Keep going around kid”, he says to me. “To the left, pass through that part of the clearing there, I’ll be right behind you”.

I start to edge my way round the clearing, never taking my eye off the shadow in the trees just ahead. I’m trying so hard to focus on it… To understand what it is that I am seeing, but I can’t. The very branches themselves seem to be moving, cracking and rippling in the shade.

​

The figure takes a sudden step forward.

“RUN!” my Grandad shouts, raising the rifle and firing a loud shot up into the air.

Unprepared for such a sudden noise my ears ring as I scramble and stumble through the forest, along a natural path of sorts between the trees, though I stumble to a halt when I realize my Grandad is not behind me.

He told me to run, but, do I go back for him?

…I have to. It’s a no-brainer.

So I swivel around and prepare to charge back to the clearing when the man himself staggers out through the bushes towards me, face white as a sheet.

“Get that damned thing out of my face, ya idiot”, he grunts as she shoves away the barrel of my rifle, and together we race through the forest. My Grandad dumps his backpack and I do likewise, leaving the equipment behind as we tear through the undergrowth, way back to where we parked the truck the other day.

When at last we see it, waiting for us on the edge of a dirt-track road, we throw ourselves inside, and my Grandad stuffs in the key and turns it with a clank, the engine revving into life.

The wheels spin and away we go, back through the wilds down the long back roads of the woodlands.

​

​

I summon the courage, after a while and once the air has cooled, to ask my Grandad what he saw. What happened after he fired the rifle.

“Thing tried to speak to me again. The deep woods, Robbie. I’m sorry for taking you there. They can screw with a man’s mind, these places. Real, real bad”.

“There was something there though, wasn’t there. Something real”.

“Yes. I think so”.

“Was it… “ I falter. “Who was it, Grandad?”

“A nightmare. That’s all. Something that shouldn’t exist, by all the laws of nature”.

“Its voice… Did you, recognize the voice?”

“You said you heard something outside your tent last night. Right?”

I nod.

“It sounded like me?”

“Yeah”, I reply.

“But it wasn’t me, was it.”

“…No”, I reply. “No, it wasn’t”.

“Sometimes we hear voices. Don’t mean they belong to anyone”.

“So why didn’t you shoot it?”

“What?” his hands flex and clench around the wheel.

“You fired the rifle, but you aimed up into the air. Not at the shadow. Why did you do that?”

To this my Grandad has no answer. He only reaches briefly across to pat my shoulder, and as the clouds swirl overhead, we spend the rest of the long drive home in a contemplative silence.

Silence, with the occasional glance to the thickets of trees that pass us by.

1,928

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

HorrorJunkie123 t1_is79ycs wrote

That'd be enough to keep me out of the forest for a long time. A bunch of Not Deer and a creepy powerful forest entity? Nope, no thanks

269

maridaz3 t1_is8x8k2 wrote

I’m so glad you both made it out while. I’d really love to hear your granddads stories.

15

minecraftcatto t1_is9081k wrote

I hate the woods and this just reinforces that feeling :D

11

Shadowwolfmoon13 t1_is930f9 wrote

Grandpa owes you an explanation of the talking shadow thing! Sounds like a skin walker. You were lucky that night in your tent. Think it was looking for grandpa.

137

MsVindii t1_is9h4ec wrote

What the hell happened to Steve, Grandad?!

That’d be the end of our hangouts until I got an answer. Fuck that.

95

The5Virtues t1_is9ngc7 wrote

Based on that mimicry I think Robert the First made a terrible sacrifice when he was young.

Once when they were young and foolhardy Robert the first and his friend Steve went out hunting in that same area of the deep woods.

They became the hunted. Tracked, followed, mimicked, taunted until one of them cracked. Robert ran—without Steve. He didn’t have to outrun them, he just had to outrun Steve.

Steve got left behind, and one of those things closed in. Those were probably Steve’s last words, as he heard something approaching him through the deep woods:

“Did you come back for me, Robert? You wouldn’t leave me behind again… would you?”

127

monkner t1_is9q3ww wrote

The deer up to their necks in the water just looking at me would be too much. Super weird, spooky and unnatural. I love it.

68

MrEket t1_is9s45f wrote

maybe the entity is sort of like controlling the woods? so that would encompass the deer and maybe use them for like spying or something? just a thought.

27

Verve_angel t1_is9xz8w wrote

Ah fuck no if Grandad is scared im trippin balls. Old people are to mean to get scared

91

LatterTowel9403 t1_isa96im wrote

I understand hunting if you need to, but after raising a fawn that I found trapped in a barbed wire fence it breaks my heart to think of someone shooting and killing such beautiful creatures for sport. You go, Bambi!

And bless you for aiming wide, brilliant way to keep the precious time with your grandpa and not hurt anything. I hope he finds peace with his past soon…

6

The5Virtues t1_isabqz4 wrote

My personal bet is the original two deer that ran from them and then ran back toward them were genuine. We never saw them again after they ran like hell.

They fled humans then realized they were running toward something far worse and went “nope, fuck that!” and doubled back right passed Roberts 1 and 2.

The deer had been seen by the shifter so now it had something to use to approach the Roberts in a form they would be familiar with. From that moment onward the Robs never saw a real deer again, just the shifter messing with them in the form of a deer.

63

Quiet_Tree_9715 t1_isbj01t wrote

Oh dang that was really creepy! Glad you both made it out, OP!

2

Thomascrane222 t1_isbo96o wrote

You need a team of 4-8 Ohioans (They have experience with this type of stuff) and 50-100 floridians with high powered rifles to take down whatever s**t that was.

9

DogWithWatermelon t1_isbpwgh wrote

He didn't fire because the thing looked like Steve just like op saw/heard his grandad in the tent

8

corsac_k t1_isfttu2 wrote

Do you think what happened to the deer was also what happened to Steve?

Your grandpa did say he wasn't sure if Steve was "exactly" dead, kinda how the deer were still breathing but not normal anymore.

He still can't bring himself to shoot Wrong-Steve.

8

Gamaray311 t1_isiamsw wrote

I’m worried about those seconds or minutes when you were separated… I mean I hope that is your real GRandad and not a skin walker or something.

9

Blessed_tenrecs t1_ispogef wrote

Wow grandpa. “Oops I think I accidentally lead us back into the haunted section of the forest. Knew it looked familiar. Sorry bout that. Let’s take the time to pack up our things and walk back to the car in a calm and orderly manner.”

6

adiosfelicia2 t1_isrowfl wrote

I agree. Though if the mimic can only repeat phrases it's heard prior, the question to Robert Sr seems off.

"You wouldn't leave me behind again, would you?"

That felt like a fresh question.

6

The5Virtues t1_isrsbrm wrote

See, I think it’s that Steve got hurt, likely by one of the shifters, and probably fell. He cries out to Robert the first for help, but Robert kept running.

The shifter closes in, likely mimicking Robert’s voice, and so Steve cries out to him, pleading for Robert not to leave him behind again, unaware that the thing he was crying out to wasn’t really Robert.

16

LaserAntlers t1_it27m6a wrote

Ideally you wouldn't even need to send that many Floridians or with rifles at all. Theoretically, a handful should be able to take care of the problem. However, if you only send 10 or so it becomes a campout party. At 20 it becomes a get-together, and at 30-40 it's like a concert or a mob. At about the 50 threshold you have a stable militia mentality going, and if you double it into two teams you can piggyback onto sports-team tribalism to create two deadly competitive militias, a pair of self motivating forces.

The guns are just so they shoot them rather than try to get some skinwussy.

5

Responsible-Cold8257 t1_itaehvf wrote

Literally camping right now (we somehow have cell service!) and this made me all the more scared. It’s pretty crowded here but I hope I don’t hear anything like that deer…

6

Bright-Bug-9356 t1_itxgf7q wrote

It probably looked like Steve. The story repeatedly hints at his friend steve being killed or taken by the things in the woods.

I don't know about you, but many people would hesitate to shoot something that looks like their best friend in the head.

Or maybe he just panicked because it was rushing him.

3

ADerbywithscurvy t1_iudvige wrote

Hey OP, the Shadow is an inverse of human hunters, but uses the same techniques!

Humans discard the soul to consume the flesh, the Shadow seems to discard the flesh to consume the soul.

  • All the animals are like empty vessels - still breathing, but void of other markers of life. Standing, but catatonic. Upright and coma-like.

Humans use decoys made of foam and fiberglass, the Shadow uses decoys made of flesh.

  • The deer in the lake show “idled vehicle” behavior; like the original they’re empty vessels, but have clearly been transported and stored for later use. Perhaps the lake storage was meant to keep them cool and keep the flies off them; humans have used lakes as refrigerators before so why not the Shadow?
  • Grandad admits he doesn’t know whether Steve is alive or dead, which implies he saw Steve in the same state as the deer, way back when. Otherwise, it would make no sense for him to even consider the possibility that Steve might be ‘alive’, as Steve was lost to the woods and the Shadow years ago. But if he saw him like the deer, it makes perfect sense to not be sure if ‘Steve’ is alive (but in a trance) or dead (but still breathing).
  • This also explains Grandad shooting wide at the end: He really doesn’t know whether the Steve he knew is still in there somewhere, or whether he’s gone entirely. He can’t risk killing his friend if there’s a chance Steve isn’t just a meat puppet for the Shadow.

Humans use calls to lure their prey, the Shadow uses calls to lure their prey.

  • It serves to reason that the Shadow didn’t use Steve’s voice against Grandad because it recognized him; it used it because it thinks that’s what a human call sounds like, and being in the deep woods it’s likely the only ‘human call’ its learned beyond Grandads. And when it used Grandads, you (the OP) didn’t come out right away, and when you did you checked on him and went back to sleep rather than moving away or going for a walk, etc.

Humans use camouflage to disguise themselves and prevent prey from ascertaining their true form, the Shadow uses camouflage to disguise itself and prevent prey from ascertaining their true form.

  • When y’all come upon the Shadow in the clearing, you say you know something is there but can’t bring it into focus, that the branches and leaves and shadows seem to be moving. This is how human camouflage is meant to work on animals - to break up the form, confuse the eye, and seeing only moving leaves or branches (if you shift) is supposed to be less alarming to prey.

Humans tend to use all these things in concert with one another, and so did the Shadow.

  • In the clearing, you come upon the Shadow having set up a hunting spot.
  • It has pulled the only Human Decoy it has, Steve. We can assume the decoy is old based on Grandads comments, so the Shadow has smartly positioned it under the canopy where you can’t tell if it’s a bit beat up, decayed, etc.
  • It has camouflaged itself behind the decoy. If it was capable of ranged attacks the way a human hunter with a gun is, it would have been able to attack from there, but instead it starts moving closer. Whatever it really is behind the Shadow camouflage, it’s a melee predator and it needs to be VERY CLOSE to attack, but the need to be close to attack seems to be causing the camouflage to interfere with the decoy it’s using to try to lure them in.
  • It uses the ‘human call’ after the decoy gets their attention. Probably hoping it makes the decoy more convincing, just like human hunters. Possibly hoping humans were highly territorial, like bucks and bears, and would rush the decoy thinking it was a rival.

If we go back to the beginning, we can see one more hunting technique: using a game trail.

  • The human hunters are making their way through the forest, and I believe at this point the Shadow is tracking them from behind. They startle the deer, who flee away, then towards, then PAST them and back the way they came. The first deer is ‘caught’ when it flees in the direction they came from, because it runs right into the Shadow that’s been following their trail.
  • As they head back, they encounter the first deer just off the same path they took going out. The first deer has one hoof on a tree trunk; so we know it’s standing almost right up against a tree. When they try to startle it, water falls off of the leaves that are directly above it as it turns its head. That’s because the Shadow is there, in the tree above, controlling the deer and ready to pounce if they approach the deer it’s using as bait.
  • Luckily, Grandad tells OP to go wide around the deer. That the Shadow doesn’t try to jump down and rush them implies that either it’s extremely slow (unlikely), or is so specifically an ambush predator that it doesn’t have the instinct to just chase prey that moves away.
  • I think something similar happened the night before they left. The Shadow - possibly using a decoy, possibly not - rubbed against the tent, and used a ‘human call’. - When OP comes out and starts checking around, he says something chirps. Just once. But he doesn’t see what chirped. This is likely the Shadow again, trying to lure him out to where it waits, camouflaged.
  • There is a second chirp, which comes only after he’s checked his grandad, stood up, and given the woods his attention again. This is the same thing that happens the next day in the clearing: When they focus their attention on its lure, it calls.
  • It fails at this point; the humans are not interested in deer decoys and bird calls. They do not come closer.
  • But the one ‘human call’ DID get the human out of its den, eventually. So humans respond to humans. Perhaps they have to be lured with human calls and human decoys.
  • Hm.
  • I guess the next logical step… would be to use both…
3

ADerbywithscurvy t1_iue09h7 wrote

Dangit, tried to edit the comment to amend my theory and managed to delete it instead. :/ Edited version was meant to read:

I got the impression the Barely Breathing Deer was a real deer, but empty. It "caught" the BBD, “ate” its soul or conciseness or whatever, and was waiting to use it as a lure to ambush the humans.

That’s why it was just off the Human Game Trail, that’s why it was pulled so close up against a tree it had a hoof on the trunk, and that’s why when Grandad tried to startle it with a clap, water fell off the leaves and branches directly over its head in perfect time with the head turning.

Whatever the fuck is hunting them, I don’t think it’s shapeshifting. I think it’s using the empty bodies of the other things it’s caught like decoys, and turning the deers head required some kind of movement on its part, like controlling a large marionette. But they didn’t go up to the deer, they went wide around it - so it couldn’t Death From Above them.

Wonder if it uses the deer as lures for other things beyond humans, like bears or mountain lions.

6