I half get the frustration when trying to pet Suzy, even tho it’s his fault for not petting her long enough the day before. But Butters is blameless. Sounds like this dude had kind of a temper and doesn’t know how to treat animals well. All he wanted was for you to go on a date with him, not the welfare of the cats. What kind of person kicks a cat and leaves it there. You said he’s old so a kick and hit into the wall could have seriously hurt him enough that a vet could be involved. You never know.

My only questions is are we allowed to pet butters for more than 2 hours? I could chill at urs all day and pet her until we both fall asleep.