Considering Pim told you the truth about the house and every rule, cut off his face instead of making you do it, and gave you more or less no consequences after you invited your rebel, rule-breaking sister into a house where you are specifically supposed to not break rules, I think he's a fairly decent guy. I'd probably be pretty pissed if I was in his position. You had one job. You literally saw her break the mask rule, after being told by the notes that a skinless man chases you if you don't wear a mask. I'm honestly surprised he didn't knock you out the moment he got you out of the bone closet. I think I would have.

​

I do have to wonder what the OG caretaker meant by "every rule wrong". Most of the rules actually do protect you -- looking at the gardener is bad, walking without a mask on is bad, opening the first and third deliveries is bad. The "no pictures" and clock winding rules are kinda bogus since they just hide the illusion, but that's two out of eight.