I'm not sure how I feel about the case as a whole but the discent does make a valid point that emergency actions should be tied to the emergency and not indefinitely. Seeing how the pause of student loans is due to COVID, the discent seem to have backed them selves into a corner where student loan pause would be tied to title 42 ending. If there is no health emergency, then both would have to end; if there is a health emergency, then both would have to stay.