Submitted by septquarantesept t3_xvz454 in newjersey
Earlier today we heard some of the worst bagels, now let’s hear who has the best bagels!
Comments
injuredmajesty t1_ir41das wrote
Goldberg's Famous Deli in Millburn. Their bagels are so crisp, airy, doughy, and flaky, there's gotta be some type of fat agent in them the way they pull apart. They're so light and fluffy, you're hungry an hour after you eat one lol
AppleJuice03270327 t1_ir4hz07 wrote
Bagel Street in Plainsboro
GoZahnGo t1_ir4jh46 wrote
One of the best that sadly is gone now was bagel bazaar in Iselin/Edison area right off of 27. They created so many different flavors, pretty nice staff, and always loved the food! Sadly they closed due to family matters.
Manhattan Bagels (I think that's the name?) in South Amboy aren't too bad though.
housespecialdelight t1_ir4tsdu wrote
Yes! I go whenever I visit my parents. The best!
housespecialdelight t1_ir4tuyu wrote
Bagel Loops in Wayne or Hot Bagel in Fair Lawn.
StrategicBlenderBall t1_ir4vr29 wrote
Terrace Bagel in Freehold or Bagel Masters in Shrewsbury.
ilikeduckconfit t1_ir4vwwt wrote
Teaneck Road Hot Bagels in Teaneck
Kosher Bagel Supreme in Springfield
Old_Cockroach_2993 t1_ir4wd3p wrote
Pops bagel wharton nj
coreynj2461 t1_ir526r5 wrote
Big thick bagels go to everything bagel in paramus on route 17. Stew leonards also has amazing onion and swiss bagels
HighPitchEricsBelly t1_ir5ghfx wrote
Dunkin Donuts in Jefferson Twsp
weaselpoopcoffee1 t1_ir5nvwy wrote
KC's in Pequannock. Still do a baker's dozen as well.
MajorScore t1_ir5pga7 wrote
Pennington Bagel in Pennington
ferocious_coug t1_ir60q2d wrote
Clinton Bagel Company in Clinton
surfnsound t1_ir68d9o wrote
I forgot about this place since it's been a long time since I lived in the area. They were really good. This is the furthest South one mentioned so far, and good bagels are few and far between down here.
Dirtylicious t1_ir6dk2j wrote
On a previous bagel post, there was someone who ranted about bagels that only had seasoning on one side.
I gotta say after reading that, I've always checked my bagel (eveything for me) for double sided seasoning. Some places definitely skimped and only did one side.
As for the OP: I'm NNJ based so - Hot Bagels in Teaneck Spring Tree Bagels Englewood
LiberaceOshKosh t1_ir6mkc7 wrote
Saddle River Road Hot Bagels in Fair Lawn. River Road Hot Bagels (no relation) on the other side of town is #2.
Thread closed.
LiberaceOshKosh t1_ir6mrrh wrote
An area where it’s a nightmare to find good bagels, Pops is solid. Nice people and great prices too.
Impossible-Duty-7122 t1_ir6mwxw wrote
Where do you live? Big state.
LiberaceOshKosh t1_ir6n0xl wrote
LOL. It’s been hell finding good bagels in The Woods. Pops in Wharton is good and The Bagel Place in Mount Arlington is good, but they’ve gone a bit crazy with their prices lately. Pops is still reasonable.
HighPitchEricsBelly t1_ir6rjmg wrote
At least somebody knew I was joking, DD bagels are trash. Only thing I know about Wharton is Sussex Meat Packing, awesome.
LiberaceOshKosh t1_ir6rrkn wrote
At least the Jefferson DD has a drive-thru…
BlackWhiteRedYellow t1_ir6xq7o wrote
Terrace is the wrong answer, sorry.
BlackWhiteRedYellow t1_ir6xsr7 wrote
Baron’s Bagels, point pleasant
StrategicBlenderBall t1_ir70sex wrote
How? The line was out the door lmao.
BlackWhiteRedYellow t1_ir70ypn wrote
Just because the shop is popular or convenient says nothing about the quality of the food.
I would put terrace bagels in the bottom 10 bagel shops I’ve tried in NJ.
StrategicBlenderBall t1_ir716lj wrote
I’ll bet you like Dunkin! At least I didn’t say Bagel Nook lol.
retrosully64 t1_ir7n3ov wrote
This! Or Round Dough with a Hole, same recipe, different owners, long story lol
DunderscoreMA t1_ir7zawm wrote
Best NJ bagel places are located in NY
the_comatorium t1_ir8gsep wrote
Bagel Loops is still delicious but holy moly have they raised their prices. I mean...economy, I get it. I forget the exact price but it's around $5 for veggie cream cheese.
Times are crazy.
nancymeadows242 t1_ir9qi0k wrote
The bread section in ShopRite *ducks
surfnsound t1_ir408zf wrote
O'Bagel in Basking Ridge.