Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

TimSPC t1_itcawyt wrote

Lido in Hackensack for thin crust.
Rose's in Garfield.
Ralph's in East Rutherford.
Lodi Pizza in.... well, Lodi.

9

TanguyIncognito t1_itcb5m5 wrote

Vic's, Bradley Beach

UVA, Bradley Beach

Federici's, Freehold

Saturn Pizza, Brick

5

insurancebykg t1_itcd5zv wrote

Federicis - Freehold.

Krispy Pizza - Old Bridge.

Frankie Feds - Freehold

2

WredditSmark t1_itcjscw wrote

Replying to TimSPC (#178,948)

Ralphs in East Rutherford is god awful. My girlfriend broke a 4 year vegan streak there and the pizza was burnt, dry and flavorless !

Ralphs in NUTLEY however is a gem

8

gnitsuj t1_itckcuc wrote

Replying to TimSPC (#178,948)

Lido in Hackensack is the answer to this question, every single time. I think if there was a single comment I've left the most times across all of reddit, it's this one, on this sub, answering this question.

3

gnitsuj t1_itckmu3 wrote

Lido Lido Lido Lido Lido, Hackensack

Star Tavern (but get it well done), Orange (I think)

Pizza Heaven, Parlin/Sayreville

Nunzio's, Sayreville/South Amboy

Marina's, East Rutherford/Wallington (I think it's closed now, but was always on my Mt Rushmore)

Joe's, Padonnos, and Proud Papas (Union)

Denino's, Brick

3

figgy6006 t1_itcphzp wrote

Tavolino’s Wallington. RIP. Closed his business.

1

DrGraffix t1_itcpws7 wrote

Delucias - raritan

Brothers - east brunswick

Deninos - matawan

2

jon8282 t1_itcsr77 wrote

Roses in Garfield Skyline Pizza in Ringwood Kinchleys in Ramsey

2

GoblinX7 t1_itcw5go wrote

The Firehouse in Garfield. Thin and crispy for the win!

1

Paulb1231 t1_itd155i wrote

Brooklyn Square in Jackson

1

beachgurl68 t1_itd55vx wrote

Arturo’s in Maplewood and Vinnie’s Pan Pizza in Millburn

7

mfsauceboy t1_itd5eq1 wrote

Razza in Jersey City and Arturo’s in Maplewood

1

Girhinomofe t1_itdi78v wrote

Straight-up Jersey pie: Pizza Town, Elmwood Park

Tomato pie: Cambiotti’s, Landing

Boardwalk pie: Maruca’s, Seaside Heights

Fancy pie: Razza, Jersey City

Just-outside-of-Jersey pie: Split Oak at Westtown Brewery, Westtown NY

2

RPizzle213 t1_itdn8oi wrote

Stella's in JC (Grove Street) Porta in JC (Grove Street) Perfect Pizza (North Bergen)

1

Big_Dinner3636 t1_itdodov wrote

Ngl, Biggies in Carlstadt has an amazing thin crust. Nellie's in Waldwick is great for thin crust too.

2

gnitsuj t1_itdqr92 wrote

Replying to paramapotomus (#181,449)

Oh nice, I think I’ve only had food from there once but I generally stick with Padonno’s and Papas because I live super close to both of them. Joe’s is very similar to Padonno’s, but I never get it because it’s on the opposite side of town. I’ll have to give Padonno’s sub a try, I never really liked their actual food other than the cheesesteaks

2

EloquentBacon t1_itdt9c5 wrote

Vic’s in Bradley Beach Brothers in Red Bank Pete & Elda’s in Neptune

1

test_test_1_2 t1_itduzy3 wrote

Wize Guys Pizza, Hackensack, is my favorite. Yummy yummy.

1

FrisbeeDays t1_itdxfp1 wrote

Sciortino’s in South Amboy & Perth Amboy, Ranchito’s in Fords, Brooklyn Boys in Edison, Federici’s in Freehold, and of course the legendary Coffaro’s in South River (r.i.p.)

Krispy is super overrated, Nunzio’s in Sayreville straight up sucks. That shit ain’t pizza

1

kuujabb t1_itdy2kj wrote

Replying to TanguyIncognito (#178,967)

Vic’s brings the business. Everyone sleeps on Vic’s with P&E five minutes away but there’s nothing like Vic’s fried calamari and a meatball pie on a Sunday. So much more flavorful than P&E with its own unique texture and tang from their sauce.

If we’re mentioning Brick spots La Fontana has hands down the best Chicken Parm and Cheese Steak pies I’ve ever had in my life. Their plain is nothing incredibly special but their specialty slices are banging.

2

NatAttack50932 t1_itdy8w9 wrote

Basile's Pizza in Hoboken is gas. Its right on the corner where Carlos bakery is and its awesome.

1

willogical85 t1_ite0bxn wrote

I can't believe nobody mentioned Kinchley's in Ramsey yet.

La Gondola in Ramsey makes a mean pie too.

Heights Pizza in Hasbrouck Heights

Lido in Hackensack, of course

But the GOAT is Delio's in South Amboy. I will die on this hill.

1

bjjblkblt t1_ite0ue6 wrote

Manco&Manco hands down OC baby!

1

blmzd t1_iteimz0 wrote

Rocco’s in Florence

1

jjmau t1_itelqqi wrote

Nancy's Townehouse in Rahway for paper thin crust.

Tony's south plainfield for standard

Jozannas middlesex for grandma pie

2

Seekhay t1_itewict wrote

Pizza Knight in Hackensack, fairly new and between his dough being one of the best ones I’ve ever had and their awesome Detroit style pizzas, this is now my only pizza place.

Try the dirty vodka pie, it’s amazing!

2

kittykat5607 t1_itezej3 wrote

Crust and crumble in Asbury Park has incredible gluten free, vegan, and regular pizza.

1

shmoobel t1_itf9z1h wrote

Sal's in East Windsor

1

TodayPuzzled t1_itfihmt wrote

Urban Tomato in Palisades Park & Edgewater

1

SoVryZen t1_itgb45c wrote

Razza - JC

Franny’s - Highlands

1

Emptyplates t1_itgx9ph wrote

Federici's Family Restaurant, Freehold. If you love a thin crust, this is the place.

Don't get the antipasto, it's garbage.

1

glorydaze2 t1_itxjc2r wrote

Santillo's..eliz.

Papas and De lorenzo's ..robbinsville

new one .. Lilo's ..hainesport nj trenton pies

1