Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

custodial_art t1_j26z645 wrote

People that say things like “will get brainwashed and become delusional” are often the most brainwashed and delusional people I know. And usually not equipped to attend college let alone understand the academic writings of such an establishment.

0

custodial_art t1_j26zq7j wrote

You can say all of those things. The real clown costume is thinking a university speaks for the general public.

5

afroggybanana t1_j275loa wrote

An unofficial, work-in-progress list of terms next to ways they could be interpreted as exclusive is not equivalent to an official university-wide banned words list.

I personally think getting upset at the phrase "kill two birds with one stone" is silly. So do, probably, most people at that university. The IT department has only catalogued that someone might complain about it because they think it's harmful to evoke imagery of violence toward animals.

But I suppose the above is a pretty long headline isn't it

2

afroggybanana t1_j277lza wrote

The reason someone might call out "American" is because Canadians also live in North "America". The reason someone might call out "Grandfather" as in "this student was grandfathered into the system where..." is because it's a gendered word.

Again, these aren't reasons to not use those words, they're not widely offensive, and they're not on a ban list. They're on a list of words that someone somewhere might find exclusive, and they're on that list as a sort of catalogue so they can be discussed internally in Stanford's IT dept.

2

wimpykidfan37 t1_j278616 wrote

Pixar should have stuck with "The Bear and the Bow".

1

afroggybanana t1_j27gkee wrote

I feel like you must be intentionally missing the point. This is not teaching material. It doesn't distract from the content of courses. It's not related at all to student activities or curriculum. It's a list of words that the IT department wanted to have an internal discussion about concerning content on the school's website. Something along the lines of "Do you guys think we're okay to use the word 'damn' on the school bookstore's website?"

Also, I've never heard someone say they've been "grandmothered" into an outdated pricing plan. And I'm not sure in which context you think you would choose one over the other. But that's beside the point.

1

afroggybanana t1_j27h32q wrote

Neat. I agree. I think it's unlikely that a reasonable person would mistake "American" for "Non-US North American". Perhaps the point of contention is related to Native Americans versus citizens of the USA. That too I think is a weird and unrealistic angle though. Who knows

1