Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Trimijopulos OP t1_ivg5qck wrote

Reply to comment by MeatballDom in Is there a moderator or a member of r/history, a historian, or an academic who would accept the challenge to debate the subject of human breeding grounds in the ancient Near East? by Trimijopulos

This is the place to discuss History.

You do not have the knowledge to decide what is a fringe hypothesis and what is a sound claim when ancient texts are involved.

You are doing no good service to History!

1

MeatballDom t1_ivg60bz wrote

> You do not have the knowledge to decide what is a fringe hypothesis and what is a sound claim when ancient texts are involved.

Seeing as I am an actual academic working at an actual university in the field of antiquity, it actually seems like I do.

1

[deleted] t1_ivg6eka wrote

[removed]

1

MeatballDom t1_ivg88ex wrote

I'm good, but you can take it to r/askhistorians and maybe you can find someone bored enough.

1