Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

ultra_prescriptivist t1_iy8oh04 wrote

Reply to comment by televisionceo in I do use Spotify more nowadays by UnnecessaryMovements

Here you go: samples of four different tracks recorded directly from Spotify and Tidal, volume matched and synched.

Good luck telling which is which.

6

televisionceo t1_iy8r6ik wrote

I can't be sure you will tell me the truth if the samples comes from the right sources so I wont be convinced today. I already did this test with spotify and tidal before switching. You also chose songs that are basically not that technical and I use hd560s.

But I'll try it anyway.

Tidal

archangel 1

Bonus sample 1

Beethnoven sample 2

Enter sandman 2

0

ultra_prescriptivist t1_iy8rux8 wrote

Alright, let's bump up the technicality and samples size.

Give me your decision on the three additional tracks and I'll shoot you a PM with the answers.

https://www.mediafire.com/file/a073avgs9ydi2kw/AB-south-of-heaven-tidal-vs-spotify.zip/file

https://www.mediafire.com/file/367klddxnjrvi7g/AB-fidgety-feet-tidal-vs-spotify.zip/file

https://www.mediafire.com/file/rknbmanhbffpa1k/AB-mahler-10-tidal-vs-spotify.zip/file

2

televisionceo t1_iy8u4lp wrote

Only if you tell me how I did with the four tracks. You can PM me if you want.

1

[deleted] t1_iy9smia wrote

[deleted]

1

televisionceo t1_iy9y10k wrote

I tried with the same volume, yes. I got 3 out of 4.

I was sent three more and I'm waiting for the results. There is one out of three where I found the production to be lacking and could not notice any difference at all between the two.

It's pretty tough. I'm not good on the technical side so I can't double check his technique. But if he does things properly, then I gotta to admit the difference is almost impossible to notice.

1