Have you tried the plague tale games?

No, I haven't, but I have heard good things about them. How is the gameplay? As you can prob see from the list I prefer fast-paced action.

The Tomb Raider games are pretty good.

If you’re into the horror genre, Dead Space just came out and it is amazing. Definitely worth checking out

It’s a slow starter during the first hour but definitely picks up, I’d say it’s a similar pace to last of us and has some similarities in gameplay - the story is really great too. If you have gamepass I believe both games are on there, if not the original generally tends to be quite reasonably priced.

You seem to like similar games to me, as I also didn’t get on so much with Witcher or RDR2 so my other recommendations might be the tomb raider trilogy and Alan wake.

Days Gone

Check out the souls games. They are in this vein. Elden Ring, Bloodborne, Dark Souls, etc.

Sounds good, I’ll be sure to try all of those games out

The mass effect series was great. Graphics are meh but story is top notch.

I’ve had this recommended a couple times so I’ll be sure to try it, thanks

I’m looking for the more straightforward movie-like storylines right now, but I still love those games (and either way I’ve played them all)

I recently got a PS5 and bloodborne quickly became one of my favorite games ever

Multiple people have said this so there is clearly something special there, I’ll be sure to give them a look

Woo you won't be disappointed... except by the facial expressions

[removed]

You're very welcome.

Based on the games you listed, there's a good chance you'll love it.