Tales of Vesperia - I put about 5 hours into it and it just wasn’t doing it for me back when it first came out. Gave it another go with the re-release and got the platinum, absolutely love the game.

Man. This thread has only 9 comments right now and Nier, Monster Hunter, and Dragon’s Crown have already been mentioned from my personal list of shame - which isn’t a big list, I usually stick with it! Going to have to give those 3 another shot