Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Mountain-Dealer8996 t1_iub69xy wrote

Reply to comment by MethodicalProgrammer in [OC] The average colour of each European country flag. by kate1hepuppy

Averaging in a “perceptual” color space doesn’t really make sense because perceptual color is non-Riemannian (source)

2

PaperReadingGuy t1_iuc5omh wrote

How can it not make sense if I'm a human and it makes total sense to me?

If the Switzerland flag is only red and white with a bit more red than white then the average should be the equivalent of mixing those quantities of ink.

Haven't artists averaged colors since forever using palettes?

Have you ever said what you just said to an artist that paints using a brush on a canvas and what was their reaction?

2

Mountain-Dealer8996 t1_iue7ze8 wrote

No, it’s not the case that mixing equal portions of red pigment and white pigment gets you a color that is perceptually mid-way between the red and white. You might get something that looks “closer” to the red or looks closer to the white. I actually have talked about this with quite a few artists. Josef Albers (abstract expressionist painter) wrote a whole book on this topic, and other non-linearities in color perception. Personally, I did my PhD thesis on the neuroscience of color perception.

2

PaperReadingGuy t1_iuf70wl wrote

I'm sorry, you could be right, but walk me through here.

If I pay an artist with brush-canvas-and-palette to mix red and white such that he can arrive at a color that is the average of the quantities of red and white on the Switzerland flag, are you saying he couldn't do that by eyeballing it?

Or are you saying he couldn't do that mechanically automatically by just mixing the exact amounts of red and white on the Switzerland flag without eyeballing it?

If you're saying the latter, that it's not automatic and the proportions are not the same as on the original flag, I could believe you, but you haven't said anything that would cause me to believe that.

If you're saying the former, there's no way I can believe in that, because then every art book on colors would have to make a major pause in explaining colors to tell me what you're trying to tell me, and no art color book does that.

Therefore it seems to me that brush-canvas-and-palette artists can totally do what you are saying can't be done - otherwise how were all the paintings that the world has accumulated in museums painted?

1