Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

RemRose t1_j97zcca wrote

Reply to comment by tkrr in Nuclear shadow, Nagasaki by allez05

That’s historically wrong but i did enjoy that reading. The scientists that developed the bombs had even advised to not use them to our government who was very adamant to just using them regardless because they felt it would end things. (Which it did) That being said the argument of well we had to cuz the fear of the unknown is also easily passed on simply because if we look slightly into the future we had this thing with russia you know the cold war where both parties could nuke each other anytime and our thought was well if thats gonna happen we have to do it first. Yet that didnt happen even with spys and intel neither party knew every single plan at all times so with that argument of “well we just didnt know what might happen so we bombed them” doesnt hold up cuz then we shoulda just did the same cuz well we dont know. Invasion keeps being brought up like thats even valid. If i can kill millions of “bad guys” and lose nobody on my side why would i send my people to die when thats my option. Regardless we bombed the shit out of people that had nothing to do with the war and no matter how you spin that its not good. War is not good, necessary at times but not good.

−1

tkrr t1_j986om2 wrote

There are some fascinating assumptions hidden in your statement, but I can’t be bothered to unpack them.

2

RemRose t1_j9870io wrote

Well considering it was all based on what you said in yours it seems both of us are just assuming shit ay? Either way have a wonderful night :)

1

tkrr t1_j987ryv wrote

Was it, though? Was it?

1