From somebody who cancelled guaranteed orders at launch for both consoles. Ended up getting both in the end and sold one of them last week (mainly to lack of available gaming time).....

You can't get it terribly wrong really because they both do a good job. I think yourself and other have raised some very valid points. The biggest one in my opinion is which exclusives you want/will enjoy the most? Add gamepass value into that weighting and your there.

Basically, how much do you actually like (as in will play and love) those big PS Exclusives? Is that more fun/value than gamepass to you?