Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

HoneydewOk1731 t1_itsgi9l wrote

Are we more concerned with the merit of the ruling or the popularity of the judge? Get a grip

−6

SkiingAway t1_ituo6up wrote

I don't see much merit in the ruling or proposed remedy.

The judge being frequently out of step with his colleagues is quite notable, as it's a bunch of his colleagues that will decide an appeal. If they all ruled pretty similarly, we could say it's unlikely for an appeal to succeed. If one guy is frequently way out of line with the views of others - it's much more likely for his decisions to get overturned on appeal.

2