Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

tryingkelly t1_jdzz5yg wrote

He seems like he’s got some good experience. But this isn’t a “one person” problem. The legislature is going to have to fund both service and the large amount needed to fix the system, and I just don’t see that happening. Best of luck to Phil

580

michael_scarn_21 t1_je04xrf wrote

This is so true. There also needs to be much more oversight than just one person because so much is rotten and he can't be everywhere at once.

137

just_planning_ahead t1_je0b9js wrote

If it is more the any "one person" that can help, then let him fall on the sword in the attempt.

I don't mean I actually want him to fail, but even seeing someone even trying would be nice. Like for example, in Milton, their stairs to their train station being removed with no timeline to replacement implying years to even decades, the alleged issue is repairing the stairs triggers ADA compliance so the MBTA needs funding and thus a legislature issue. Milton seem to have tried to pull every string they have between political avenues and even lawsuits. But the MBTA barely responds back to Milton, much less than actually act like their hands are actually tied rather than acting like one tying hands by stonewalling to even give a response.

If the issue is the legislature, then it would be nice to see the MBTA actually act like that implying that it wants to improve but can't rather than the above which implies they just have no interest. If we look back to just Poftak, then just remembering during the year before the pandemic, he even used to say that the MBTA doesn't need more money as more money don't speed up their "fixes".

69

tryingkelly t1_je0bmku wrote

I feel weirdly like I need to defend the T here and I don’t want too. He’s probably going to fail. Massachusetts politics are insular and corrupt, and notoriously unfriendly to outsiders, and he’s gonna need political cooperation to succeed.

43

Maxpowr9 t1_je0tdv0 wrote

Yep. It's why the State Legislature fought so hard against the FTA taking over. Same reason they're fighting against being audited. Corruption is likely rampant in State Government and MBTA.

32

wittgensteins-boat t1_je1bcge wrote

In what manner did the legislature fight against Federal Transit Administration?

Citations needed.

16

[deleted] t1_je4ueh8 wrote

[deleted]

2

wittgensteins-boat t1_je4z4cj wrote

Not the legislature's move.

A crisis of repairs needed for new rolling stock to be able to operate on the line, after an egregious fire.

That is safety compliance expenditure, even if inadequate, compared to decades of inadequate funding for capital maintenance.

1

SkiingAway t1_je0uzrd wrote

Eh, NYS is just as infamously difficult and corrupt.

22

spitfish t1_je1nurw wrote

> Massachusetts politics are insular and corrupt,

The only thing we can do to prevent that is to get involved in local politics.

4

wittgensteins-boat t1_je1ayh5 wrote

Lack of Accessibility makes the MBTA a class action lawsuit away from properly fixing this and other stations.

4

Doctrina_Stabilitas t1_je1dkso wrote

The mbta is more accessible than other comparable American transit systems, if you think that’s not the case, I encourage you to take the Orange line and listen to the beeping

10

wittgensteins-boat t1_je1x2kq wrote

I agree that it is the case, thanks to the settlement of the Feingold suit in 2006, and the two decades of investment since then.

New York only in the last year settled a similar accessibility suit, and is three decades away from coming into substantial compliance, under the settlement funding process.

And has another active suits relating to buses.

8

bakgwailo t1_je1i9dl wrote

The MBTA has known the stairs were crumbling for years. The station itself is accessible by multiple other at grade and level entrances from the sidewalk.

1

hopefulcynicist t1_je0xtvn wrote

Not a one person problem for sure, but if this guy comes in with an actual agenda he can publicly call out / turn the screws on the legislature.

Some public/official finger pointing back at the legislature is long overdue.

11

william-t-power t1_je0zy5x wrote

One person can be the solution. One person who has a clear perspective of the problem(s), a vision to move forward, and the power to do so; solves problems by the perspective and vision being good and getting people on board from the top down. That's how one person solves a big problem. They find the solution, get people to agree and work in concert, and sideline the people in the way.

Most people, though, aren't capable of this. Hopefully this guy is.

7

alohadave t1_je0w5zq wrote

> The legislature is going to have to fund both service and the large amount needed to fix the system

Yeah, I wish this guy luck, but if the legislature doesn't cooperate, he's DOA.

5

7screws t1_je09cfm wrote

if it was a one person problem probability states we would have found a person by now.

3

calinet6 t1_je1dizl wrote

Yes, correct, it’s complex and there are a lot of dependencies, but at the same time the difference a good leader can make even mired in challenge is night and day compared to a bad one.

3