Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

StepfordMisfit t1_j24y85e wrote

Excluding a self-published book by an acquaintance with 6 5-star ratings, most probably out of guilt...

Highest is The Nature of Remains by Ginger Eager with a 4.74 average. It only has 38 ratings and 14 reviews, but won a legit award. Fantastic book.

Next is I'm Glad My Mom Died by Jennette McCurdy with 4.59 average.

Lowest is A Conspiracy of Tall Men by Noah Hawley at 3.07 avg. I didn't rate it and don't remember it but now I'm feeling a little bad for all the 3s I've given to books that were just ok.

8

ChaDefinitelyFeel OP t1_j24z6mq wrote

Theres a weird psychological thing where people don't want to give a book a 1 or 2 star rating, even for things that are really bad. Instead of 1-5 it might as well be a scale of 3-5. Even Mein Kampf has a 3.18, to put things in perspective.

5

claudiaqute t1_j253t3d wrote

I don't remember my lowest average one either despite giving it 3 stars. I always say 3 stars is my 'this is fine' rating, meaning I didn't necessarily like it but I didn't actively dislike it. While scrolling through all this I was a little shocked by how many 3 star books I just don't really remember because I guess they are just the most forgettable for not being particularly liked or disliked.

3