Submitted by rabidpiano86 t3_ycgxr7 in books
SSSS_car_go t1_itmmjb1 wrote
I’ve spent the past 30 years as a freelance copy editor for nonfiction books and other documents, and have worked for dozens of publishers. The short answer to the question of errors that make it into the published book is that publishers don’t want to pay for quality.
Many tasks in the life of a manuscript are now handled by freelancers, and in some cases every step except project management is outsourced. So that’s one issue, that managers might not have access to the best copy editor out there. But another issue is that good copy editors—like me!—get tired of doing what amounts to pro bono work: when publishers pay very low project/page rates, they’ll get lower-quality work. When I accept work from publishers who pay a low rate, I read it only once then skim once more quickly. It’s far from ideal, and leaves lots of bugs no doubt, but it’s what they’re willing to pay for.
On the other hand, I have other clients who pay by the hour, and tell me to spend as much time as needed to catch every error. With those clients I read three or sometimes four times, and very few errors slip by me.
SailboatAB t1_itn7kwr wrote
This. At some point somebody decided they'd rather have a little more money at the cost of reputation and clear communication. Many places regard copy editing as an unnecessary luxury.
Gyoza-shishou t1_itnsrv9 wrote
So I guess it's a good thing I tend to proofread my shit before even saving it, yes?
SSSS_car_go t1_itpqpsj wrote
Yes, but keep in mind that we all have a blind spot when it comes to our own writing and we should never attempt to copy edit ourselves. This is why self-published books are so laughably full of errors, and also why the manuscripts I’ve worked on that presented the most challenges have been those with a note attached from the author: “This won’t need much work because I have [or my wife has—for some reason it’s never a husband!] already copy edited it.”
commandrix t1_itofkrl wrote
Yes, I was going to say that just having a few typos in a book is probably an editing issue. Probably editors that are overworked and/or underpaid, so of course they're going to miss stuff. And, as a writer, I know I might occasionally use a wrong word if I get too tired or distracted.
Plus there are things that not even the best editor on the planet can fix...
I-suck-at-golf t1_itoigi2 wrote
Did you get a high score on the SATs?
RealMudflapper t1_itput8b wrote
What are you trying to say?
I-suck-at-golf t1_itpwjc7 wrote
Being able to RE-read something over and over is a skill. I figured they probably did well on standardized tests.
RealMudflapper t1_itpzbnk wrote
Glad I asked. Your comment came off sounded critical which is probably why people downvoted you.
I-suck-at-golf t1_itq7smf wrote
Yeah. Thanks for asking. That’s Reddit I guess. It’s ok.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments