Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

hasimple OP t1_j9z22ue wrote

Reply to comment by Hoodieninj in Verity by Colleen Hoover was awful. 2 star rating by hasimple

i could care less about a books popularity if it’s not good it’s not good and imma state what i think isn’t good which i did

all the points you said where vaild but also does not change my opinion on how much i hated it just how this won’t change ur opinion

thank u for taking the time to state what u believe tho

8

Hoodieninj t1_j9z4sij wrote

That's totally fair. Also, wasn't trying to accuse you of disliking it because of its popularity, I meant that as more of a general observation from other criticisms I've seen. Sorry if it came across that way!

3

hasimple OP t1_j9z66ns wrote

oh no worries at all i know text isn’t the best way of showing what was actually meant to say! i totally respect you stating what you feel is good about the book

i didn’t really go in depth of what you said my bad

the random death did grab my attention but it also left me thinking they could’ve meet another way that wasn’t so gruesome

the indication of him falling in love with her was when they where in bed and i think they where doing it for the first time i can’t remember and he said he fell in love with her at the coffee shop or something like that i could misinterpreted wrong but when he said that i was just thinking “you fell in love with her after seeing that???? “

the sleepwalking just seemed very unnecessary to me but i would’ve thought she was crazy anyway

i get the tension building of her reading the book slow but man it was very annoying

it really wasn’t a fun read for me more of a wow i can’t believe i read this. and i still can’t get over the fact someone cried over it but hey everyone has different reactions

1