Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

dustofdeath t1_j1hz9c7 wrote

Menthol only triggers cold receptors. Same way a cold air would (which may lead to runnier mucus).

Wasabi triggers increased mucus production that could lead to runnier mucus, clearing up some congestion.

None actually reduce the swelling to open up sinuses.

212

EntrepreneurLoud497 t1_j1jys9c wrote

We have cold receptors? I thought we perceived cold as heat leaving our body ...

11

EntrepreneurLoud497 t1_j1jz23e wrote

"Warm receptors will turn up their signal rate when they feel warmth—or heat transfer into the body. Cooling—or heat transfer out of the body—results in a decreased signal rate. Cold receptors, on the other hand, increase their firing rate during cooling and decrease it during warming" Yap two different receptors for different purposes... the more you learn :O

21

Thetakishi t1_j1kchpe wrote

I mean that's the physical reason that's happening (or menthol etc is tricking them), but we call them cold recepting because relative to base temperature, they (the neurons) fire more when it's colder compared to heat sensing which fire more with heat (or spicy like capsaicin and some other compounds). I'm actually unsure (fairly confident there is) if there is multiple subtypes of each.

edit: just noticed the other reply was to yourself, sorry!

3

Thetakishi t1_j1kcn83 wrote

Are you sure menthol doesn't cause the sinuses to reflexively contract? Actually wondering.

2

Dez2011 t1_j1kpr4z wrote

You are correct. The veins in the sinuses swell causing the feeling of a stuffy nose. Menthol and those vicks sinus smelly sticks cause the veins to contract, making room for more airflow to move through. I recently remembered the vicks sticks my grandmother used when I was a kid and looked it up to see how they worked since you don't actually inhale any fluid/medication.

7

dustofdeath t1_j1kdq1p wrote

If you get too strong of a dose, sure you might close the sinus spinxter (?) muscle on instinct.

But that "cool" effect of guns, toothpastes etc is just triggering the receptors with false signals.

2