Submitted by AutoModerator t3_ywvph3 in askscience
Pharisaeus t1_iwn2u72 wrote
Reply to comment by ashara_zavros in Ask Anything Wednesday - Engineering, Mathematics, Computer Science by AutoModerator
metallic water container
is not a very strict definition so it's hard to tell what exactly you mean :)
In order to place something in orbit you need to accelerate it horizontally to about 7.5km/s. The issue of using a "cannon" is that such device applies force only for a very short time when object is moving through the barrel. This means the acceleration has to be extremely high and as a result the applied force has to be very high as well. So your "container" has to be able to withstand compressive stress.
There is another, more problematic issue - once you leave the barrel you hit the atmosphere, and hitting atmosphere when moving at such velocity will cause atmospheric compression and heating (just like when spacecraft come back from orbit) slowing you down. So the container has to be able to withstand the heating, and the cannon has to eject the payload much faster than orbital velocity.
If you can get material like that, then you could launch it in such a way :) However, a more "practical" version of this idea would be to build a very long vacuum tunnel somewhere in high mountains. Long tunnel means you accelerate over longer distance, and if you place the nozzle of the cannon very high (let's say 8km) you hit much thinner atmosphere.
ashara_zavros t1_iwpt1sd wrote
Your last paragraph describes a different kind of cannon.
Thanks for the effort, but all you’ve done is describe the problems with orbital launch that affec any transportation method. I’m more interested in knowing if there’s a currently viable solution.
But, again, thanks anyway.
Pharisaeus t1_iwq42zo wrote
> different kind of cannon
How so? It's a cannon, just with a very long barrel and without the impractical "instant acceleration" issue. It's pretty much the only semi-realistic design.
> that affec any transportation method
Only that it doesn't. Rockets accelerate pretty slowly, at 1.5-2G, so they have no significant issues with crossing through atmosphere or with high-G loads during acceleration.
> if there’s a currently viable solution
Does SpinLaunch count or is it also "different kind of cannon"?
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments