Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Coomb t1_isofdg2 wrote

Reply to comment by ra3_14 in How does vaccinating trees work? by ra3_14

No, it's actually a vaccine. Plants have immune systems that are in some way analogous to ours, although because they have much different biology the details are not the same.

However, in this case the vaccine works like a vaccine would in a human: a non-virulent strain of a potential pathogen (here a fungus) is injected into the tree, causing the tree to develop an immune response to the similar-enough pathogenic fungus, which allows the tree to resist infection from that fungus.

2

Xilon-Diguus t1_isohgu0 wrote

I am unaware of any adaptive immune responses in plants (ie what a vaccine would work on). There are some attempts to prime the innate immune responses in order to illicit a stronger response, but that is not a vaccine.

[source]

6

NakoL1 t1_ispa1hs wrote

that article does say there's "acquired resistance" and "immune memory" in plants, though clearly with a completely mechanism compared to mammals. It's right there in the "Key Points" summary

3

newappeal t1_isspgr0 wrote

In addition to acting through a different mechanism, it also has a slightly different function from mammalian immune memory. Systemic Acquired Resistance is first and foremost a method of raising the immune response throughout the plant in response to a local infection. This is predicated on the fact that plants grow in a modular, only semi-deterministic manner with different organs living relatively independently of each other (at least compared to how most animals' bodies work) and the fact that they don't have a circulatory system that rapidly transports substances between organs.

Such a system wouldn't be useful in mammals, because a pathogen in the bloodstream is going to travel just as fast as any endogenous signal, and (since mammals are motile) an infection at one location in the body is unlikely to be followed by a subsequent infection at another location. In contrast, sessile organisms beset by e.g. a fungal pathogen can expect to be infected at multiple locations over a fairly short period of time.

2

Nervous_Breakfast_73 t1_isqbvck wrote

do you know what you are talking about? nothing in this article states anything related to how vaccines works in us. as far as I remember plants have some genes that can detect pathogens and elicit some immune response, but it's not adaptive as in us mammals. pls don't spread misinformation after skimming over a Wikipedia article

1